Samsung found to not have willfully infringed Apple's patents

30 January, 2013
This prevents any additions to the $1.049 billion that Samsung still has to pay Apple.

Sort by:

  • D
  • AnonD-109269
  • ixD
  • 04 Feb 2013

AnonD-59079, 30 Jan 2013In the delusional mind of Samdung fanboy, it's always Apple... moreTrue

    • k
    • kirk
    • 9xB
    • 31 Jan 2013

    AnonD-35392, 30 Jan 2013Are you high, you think people bought galaxy s s2 and note ... morelol. i still find it funny whenever somebody says that some people mistakenly buy the s2 thinking it's an iphone. who the hell buys a product that costs a significant amount of money without checking once or twice that it is what it is? hahaha. remember the 2 jimmy kimmel episodes where people were asked what they think about the "new" iphone? well i guess apple has a point in suing samsung. hahaha

      • n
      • ngashville
      • NvS
      • 31 Jan 2013

      apple is a company that cant depend on its self its product's components are made by other companies such as samsung and sony so it has to be in good terms with other companies for it to survive

        • k
        • kirk
        • 9xB
        • 31 Jan 2013

        my mini 2, 30 Jan 2013I agree did you reply to my post? who reported it? lol damn these fan boys! hahaha

          • D
          • AnonD-104517
          • U{2
          • 31 Jan 2013

          Denzo, 30 Jan 2013So Sony.. everything is made in China.. You havent done eco... moreu didnt understood what i m saying... if u n ur frndz have to meet outside home somewhere were u all can gather... so china here is the place of gathering n assembling... what kind of economics is involved in that?? world is full of fanboyism... look at my comments carefully i never said anything bad about apple coz i like it... same way i dont hate any brand... u ppl think that every person here is a fanboy of particular brand... dont know y gsmarena doesnt block comments reflecting fanboyism or hatret... n my comment in context with manufacturing of a particula part, not about designing which is what i have written n if u carefully read my comment then u will find that i mentioned the word "elegant" before ios which means i like its os... dont hate the people too much coz u fight with fanboys n haters more than apple n samsung court fights... n for the economics, let me tell u that i am working in share markets who has much more knowledge of economics... n also this comment is not only for u but all haters n fanboys who thinka every people comment here coz they love a specific brand n hate all other brand... got it??

            • D
            • AnonD-68354
            • vww
            • 30 Jan 2013

            Anonymous, 30 Jan 2013Apple gets more margin from their iphones because apple pro... moreThis case is a landmark one cos it demonstrates the outrageous flaws in our patent n judicial systems! It's a well known fact that Judge Koh, who's of S.Korean origin herself has a personal vendetta against Samsung n is also 1 of the most inexperienced judges to have ever been promoted to the post! The case has been marred by controversy from the beginning, as the very grounds of the case are almost baloney and calls into question the efficiency of the USPTO after it granted ridiculous patents to (Cr)Apple! This case should be an eye opener for the Federal Govt. 2 drastically improve the judicial system n the USPTO, if they both wanna avoid further shame! I think this is headed all the way 2 the Supreme Court n Judge Koh is now trying 2 overcompensate or has maybe decided 2 side with the truth 4 a change! Well, wherever there's (Cr)Apple you're guaranteed such controversy! Remember Antennagate n Job's infamous remarks that he was right n all the users were wrong, even though it was evident he was dead wrong? Sums up (Cr)Apple's arrogant n bullying attitude n all-out greed - it's Job's legacy after all!

              • i
              • iush
              • ttv
              • 30 Jan 2013

              Guy with guts, 30 Jan 2013Yes the 5th row of icons was the best innovation i have eve... moreThe only phone I love from samsung is Note 2. Played it for 30 mins and then I felt ip5 so boring and small. And another thing I prefer from Samsung is their premium suite upgrade. I hate that Apple is not making phone so capable like note 2 but I am sure they will wow the world again soon with lots of innovation and rule the industry for another 5 years

                • i
                • iush
                • ttv
                • 30 Jan 2013

                Someone, 30 Jan 2013Don't be like that. The reason why Apple makes huge prof... moreIt's true apple sell that many phones but it's also true that their profits margin is huge compared to their revenue. Samsung sold 63 million phones at the same but their profit is lesser than apple..calculations show that Apple has 34% margin where as samsung has only 13%

                  • S
                  • Someone
                  • Mx@
                  • 30 Jan 2013

                  Anonymous, 30 Jan 2013Apple gets more margin from their iphones because apple pro... moreDon't be like that.

                  The reason why Apple makes huge profit is because they manage to sell 47 MILLION iPhone's.

                  Don't you think ANY other company would love to have those kind of sales on it's FLAGSHIP phone??

                    • ?
                    • Anonymous
                    • t}4
                    • 30 Jan 2013

                    Apple gets more margin from their iphones because apple provides inferior hardware configuration and overprices the iphone.
                    Thus apple generates more revenue despite having lesser market share.

                      • E
                      • Eltzer the 3rd
                      • nw}
                      • 30 Jan 2013

                      AnonD-107098, 30 Jan 2013i think apple made a free ad on all samsung gadgets, before... moreI totally agree on that one ! same story here

                        • G
                        • Guy with guts
                        • s8g
                        • 30 Jan 2013

                        iush, 30 Jan 2013Apple is the most innovative company, Samsung can copy it's... moreYes the 5th row of icons was the best innovation i have ever seen in my life. Peace out ifanboy whats the point of a phone to be the lightest and thinnest and putting it in a fat case for protecting the metal. For that instance Plastic is then way better than glass and aluminium. I'm not a fanboy either i hate samsung but i hate apple too.

                          • S
                          • Someone
                          • Mx@
                          • 30 Jan 2013

                          AnonD-107098, 30 Jan 2013i think apple made a free ad on all samsung gadgets, before... moreAnd yes you may have switched to Samsung from Apple.

                          But it isn't Apple who are worried about Samsung - it's the OTHER manufacturers who are worried about Samsung.

                          As we've seen from Apple world record breaking Financial Quarter, Apple are doing just fine.

                            • D
                            • AnonD-107098
                            • UD%
                            • 30 Jan 2013

                            Someone, 30 Jan 2013They may not make the phone. But they designed the phone... morei think apple made a free ad on all samsung gadgets, before i'm used to buying only apple product until the time i read the news of apple suing samsung, this time i know that Apple has a competitor cheaper and nicer product that's the reason i bought samsung products

                              • s
                              • sammee
                              • UD%
                              • 30 Jan 2013

                              AnonD-78115, 30 Jan 2013Neither willfully infringed nor even infringement, only if ... morei think apple made a free ad on all samsung gadgets, before i'm used to buying only apple product until the time i read the news of apple suing samsung, this time i know that Apple has a competitor cheaper and nicer product that's the reason i bought samsung products

                                • m
                                • my mini 2
                                • v0q
                                • 30 Jan 2013

                                [deleted post]I agree

                                  • D
                                  • Denzo
                                  • IPt
                                  • 30 Jan 2013

                                  AnonD-104517, 30 Jan 2013apple only makes the elegant ios which they make themselves... moreSo Sony.. everything is made in China.. You havent done economics have you

                                    • S
                                    • Someone
                                    • Mx@
                                    • 30 Jan 2013

                                    AnonD-104517, 30 Jan 2013apple only makes the elegant ios which they make themselves... moreThey may not make the phone.

                                    But they designed the phone both inside and internally.

                                    What components work best where they go what materials to use. And the building process.

                                    Watch the videos on the Apple website.

                                      • D
                                      • AnonD-104517
                                      • U{S
                                      • 30 Jan 2013

                                      AnonD-69205, 30 Jan 2013Hello Samsung is not making screen for apple Sony is making... moreapple only makes the elegant ios which they make themselves while on the hardware part, they dont make any single hardware, not even body of the phone... dont u wonder y every apple product is assembled in china while their HQ is in cupertino, CA, US??

                                        • D
                                        • AnonD-78115
                                        • KSi
                                        • 30 Jan 2013

                                        Neither willfully infringed nor even infringement, only if apple had the guts in their ass to face samsung professionally.