Apple loses appeal, $440M patent infringement fine stands

17 January 2019
The company was ordered to pay the sum for infringing LTE licenses.

Sort by:

Galaxy Note 10, 17 Jan 2019Patent trolls....at least they must have developed and serv... moreKarma is fun to watch

    • J
    • JOHN
    • 8x1
    • 17 Jan 2019

    [deleted post]and they will lol

      Patent trolls....at least they must have developed and served single market before asking for such huge penalties for violation. Or, there must be a mechanism outside court to measure the licensing or violations in line with the size of the operation.

      But the problem for Apple is that they set a bad precedence of suing others...now coming back

        • F
        • FaceGle
        • Q5x
        • 17 Jan 2019

        FinestBezels, 17 Jan 2019I hope the iPhones prices go down.Definitely, it's a big NO, NO, NO.
        Since, apol is fining about a million dollars because of infringement patent of VirnetX and Qualcomm, rest assured, they will not lower down the price. Consumer will cover up that amount by buying their products. Mark my word.

          • ?
          • Anonymous
          • 0p}
          • 17 Jan 2019

          Apple gets a taste of their own medicine.

            I hope the iPhones prices go down.

              • g
              • gagaga
              • IW@
              • 17 Jan 2019

              coming from apple device(iphone8) then switched to android(mate20pro), I would say apple will get what they deserved. this serves them right. been an apple fan for years until iphone8 when i could no longer stomach their, whatever they are doing(no fast charger out of the box, high cost of repairs... etc)...

                • F
                • FaceGle
                • Q5x
                • 17 Jan 2019

                Apple vs. Qualcomm because of stealing the patent and apol share it to Intel.
                Apple vs. VirnetX because of patent infringement.

                Who else?

                  • ?
                  • Anonymous
                  • 4DI
                  • 17 Jan 2019

                  FinnishInquisition, 17 Jan 2019Patent trolls are literally a cancer that needs to be eradi... moreThey deserve to lose as much money as they are right now.

                  Apple can lose the rest of the year for all I care, oh and no one cares if that hurts your feelings.

                    • D
                    • AnonD-241270
                    • 3E0
                    • 17 Jan 2019

                    FinnishInquisition, 17 Jan 2019Patent trolls are literally a cancer that needs to be eradi... moreYeah, its logical, that whats i call karma, everybody know first iPhone introduction and Steve Jobs saying: "we have patent, we patent this and that", and now what?! now they are proving they dont patent anything, just use it without license or paying royalities to the patetns owners.

                    bleeeeeh, i like this, more and more companies should do this to crApple, 2019 will be the last year for them, byyyye apple, for good. OVERPRICED J_NK

                      • T
                      • Tech guy
                      • ADh
                      • 17 Jan 2019

                      appelol

                        • J
                        • Johnny
                        • kU$
                        • 17 Jan 2019

                        FinnishInquisition, 17 Jan 2019Patent trolls are literally a cancer that needs to be eradi... moreNo more absurd than suing over the shape of an icon, or the shape of a corner... how those patents were even allowed is beyond me. This looks more like karma to me.

                          • 1
                          • 123
                          • 0BE
                          • 17 Jan 2019

                          all is good, they will add 100$ up their price tags and all is good. 2020 iphone 11 around 1600$ and all is good fines everything

                            • D
                            • AnonD-558092
                            • 45}
                            • 17 Jan 2019

                            I preferred how The Register related the news. Instead of being polite, they straight up called VirnetX for what they are, a Patent Troll company.

                            Though I hate Apple, and I also hate Patent Trolls... Nah, Apple hate prevails. They are also patent trolls with their rounded icon patents and layout patents (can't believe you can patent a grid of icons) and so much more...

                            Would have loved it if they patented their darn notch. Why did they had to patent a layout and not this abomination?!

                              Patent trolls are literally a cancer that needs to be eradicated. I hope the appeal is granted, and that Apple wins in the end. This is just absurd.