Apple wins another injunction against Motorola in Germany

02 March, 2012
This was regarding the patent that describes the bounce animation in photo gallery while scrolling.

Sort by:

  • D
  • AnonD-12453
  • KiK
  • 04 Mar 2012

Appleftw, 04 Mar 2012Yeah!!! That teaches you copy cat a lesson, not to copy App... morewhere the hell have you been dude? samsung is sued first then motorolla.. they succeed delaying galaxy's tab sales..

    • m
    • marte
    • wrj
    • 04 Mar 2012

    Appleftw, 04 Mar 2012Yeah!!! That teaches you copy cat a lesson, not to copy App... moreone look at your nickname and boom
    not an apple fanboy...
    ha ha

      • h
      • hitesh
      • YQr
      • 04 Mar 2012

      motorola is best as always

        • A
        • Appleftw
        • sG$
        • 04 Mar 2012

        Yeah!!! That teaches you copy cat a lesson, not to copy Apple. Apple should also sue Samsung from existence, because all Samsung can do is copy... They can't innovate anything besides their lame over-saturated colours. Btw I'm not a fanboy... I've owned the galaxy s2 and sold it in 2 months because it sucked so bad. lags,bugs/glitches, burn in from low life span screen(LCD last like 10 times longer), cheap plastic, screen way too damn bright... I can't even use in bed or I'll be blind.. No hate guys just being honest, sorry to bring Samsung into this LOL.

          • b
          • btc5472
          • 0cJ
          • 04 Mar 2012

          Anonymous, 03 Mar 2012motorola is best in the worldMotorola is crap. Ive had 4 of their phones and they all turned themselves off and got REALLY slow. Including the droid x and the x2. I had 40 apps and that is what caused all of the problems. When i uninstalled them, most of the problems went away. But i have to admit, the droic razr is really good. Even though the first phone my friend got was broken

            • k
            • kongming
            • 0C3
            • 03 Mar 2012

            The right for creativity is really something to be protected. But to file injunctions after injunctions just to get rid of your competitors is simply way too dishonorable. It's quite obvious that this measure has been habitualy used to gain false supremacy in the market. More and more, Apple's insecurity towards the innovations done by other companies is becoming apparent. Technology is like the gift of fire. It's illumination and warmth has to be shared by many, and not hoarded by one.

              • T
              • TheVerdictIs
              • mpT
              • 03 Mar 2012

              Anonymous, 02 Mar 2012apple has done the right thing. As microsoft secretly paten... moreYeah you said it 'your invention' it isn't Apple's invention in the first place to be suing over. It's like Apple uses every1 else patents and says 'hey u cant sue us, we need this to make our phone work'and the courts let them??. But when a company does the same to Apple the laywers come filing out of Apple's HQ like its Christmas and the Turkeys ripe. If thats the fact how's about the dude who invented the 1st Mobile phone just sue everyone and stop all company's from manufactoring the mobile phone, or the geezer who invented the Net?? pathetic.

                • h
                • hoobs
                • 3Ax
                • 03 Mar 2012

                i do find it quite funny i read on a news website that since google bought motorola they want to stop the patent wars and stop suing each other over silly things but continue with these law suits. only complain about the ones they cant win

                  • D
                  • AnonD-34870
                  • PB5
                  • 03 Mar 2012

                  This is the silliest legal battle just for a gallery animation? Apple can sue every animation artist on this world.

                    • D
                    • AnonD-42166
                    • fw7
                    • 03 Mar 2012

                    AnonD-42936, 03 Mar 2012I think it's cool that way. I don't know if it's being gree... moreYou talk like Apple actually invented all their patents. The slide to unlock function was actually invented by a small company called Neonode. Not ******* Apple. They just managed to patent it first. Apple will fall hard one day in the future. Just like I laughed when Stevie croaked. How long before Apple faces a anti trust hearing. Happened to Microsoft when they got to big and bullied smaller companies. The wheel turns Apple!!

                      • ?
                      • Anonymous
                      • pTi
                      • 03 Mar 2012

                      motorola is best in the world

                        • T
                        • Tim
                        • iiH
                        • 03 Mar 2012

                        Jack spyro, 02 Mar 2012MOTOROLA invented mobile! Does apple have patent right copy... moreIf you notice in the article they did try and sue for their invetion, innovation and technology realated to communications ... but it's a "standard" now. So they can't sue. Pfft.

                        Yet Apple can patent BS things like slide to unlock, thin bezzle etc.

                        Pathetic System.

                        I see Apple has patented viewing a 3D image without a screen alos ... Ummm it'scalled a hologram - try watching Starwars and Star Trek in the 70's.

                          • A
                          • A-no-ny-mous
                          • IVx
                          • 03 Mar 2012

                          patent for animation? thank god apple did not patent stuff like 3d games animation - they could sue the whole world for that

                            • ?
                            • Anonymous
                            • P$W
                            • 03 Mar 2012

                            motohate, 02 Mar 2012its time motorola learnt things the hard way.. their device... morebadly disguised troll is a badly disguised troll

                              • n
                              • niki
                              • TK4
                              • 03 Mar 2012

                              Stop the copy cat attitude and come out with unique feature for "us" users. Otherwise all devices feel the same. "Yawn"

                                • A
                                • AdamBoy64
                                • vuB
                                • 03 Mar 2012

                                motohate, 02 Mar 2012its time motorola learnt things the hard way.. their device... moreI can see from your username you have a deep-seated resent towards them that's not going to be changed by anyone online.

                                But I've found Motorola devices to be quite good.

                                  • E
                                  • EU
                                  • LHf
                                  • 03 Mar 2012

                                  i dont have feeling for corporation, i dont love or hate thhis or that corporation.... i just think that software patents are holding up evolution slowing it down so that some corporation can make money...

                                    • D
                                    • AnonD-42936
                                    • 9Lm
                                    • 03 Mar 2012

                                    I think it's cool that way. I don't know if it's being greedy but Apple has the right to defend their creation. If All phones have the same styles or ui then there is no sense buying a new one. Creativity people don't hate Apple. I own a BB but i also have an iPad.
                                    Bottomline, every brand has to come up with a new innovation. Healthy competition not copy-ing!

                                      • ?
                                      • Anonymous
                                      • syc
                                      • 02 Mar 2012

                                      ABOUT TIME !!!
                                      Apple, Samsung and Motorola cases all thrown out in German court. Finito no more :)

                                        • j
                                        • jan
                                        • nMM
                                        • 02 Mar 2012

                                        ORANGE, 02 Mar 2012APPLE THATS MISERABLE!! really hate such stupid policies of... moreAgreed. Hope Apple to fail quickly. These suing practices, based on silly issued, are repulsive