Sony Xperia Z vs. HTC Butterfly: A tale of two screens

12 March 2013
Flagships have evolved significantly during the past year, and in screen terms in particular, what once looked like overkill has become the gold standard for both size and resolution. HTC was the first of the major manufacturers to set the bar high...

Sort by:

  • A
  • Ali
  • rK4
  • 13 Mar 2013

Xperia z is the winner and butterdly is the runner in many cases

    • m
    • mas
    • q80
    • 13 Mar 2013

    Why the hell do people care about viewing angles? ive never understood why this is important in a phone

      • k
      • karan
      • 3aT
      • 13 Mar 2013

      just wait for tomorrow
      big daddy's gonna put everyone in place ;)

        • x
        • xperia ax
        • PSv
        • 13 Mar 2013

        display issues i think are limited to certain batches of the xz. there are xz's with better viewing angles and contrast levels. xz uses sharp and jdc panels. the sharp ones are generally better. they look like the butterfly's i think.

        i just don't understand why sony is using those inferior displays on some—well many of their units.

          • D
          • AnonD-87222
          • 3ZH
          • 13 Mar 2013

          Yeah, unfortunately the display quality on Sony phones is really surprisngly weak. I have an Arc and believed the marketing hype. I still like the phone but oh gosh, the display.. and it seems like they're still using the same kind of display on Xperia T and now Xperia Z, just with slightly better contrast which doesn't help it much. Other than the screen (and battery life under stress) the Xperia Z is a very good phone. The best one Sony had so far. Things are not looking good for them since the Galaxy S4 is around the corner and it looks like the Xperia Z couldn't sell as well as we all thought, clearly it's the last few days for Sony until they'll have to consider MAJOR price cuts.

          Unless Galaxy S4 will have the rumored S3-ish soap-holder design. In that case Sony may simply win with design.

            • D
            • AnonD-117929
            • pT2
            • 13 Mar 2013

            xperia z winner.
            thank you sony

              • D
              • AnonD-114473
              • KiT
              • 13 Mar 2013

              AnonD-85611, 12 Mar 2013Looks like Sony is the worst manufacturer when we are talki... moreworst screen??
              do you ever look whats Xperia P screen like??

                • D
                • AnonD-57609
                • rXC
                • 13 Mar 2013

                I can confirm that the screen is of extremely high quality, judging by history, Sony phones have always been criticized for viewing angles by professional reviewers, but soon after everyone comes to find that the screen has no such issues. Reviewers tend to like the idea of spoiling the user experience as well as letting gaps for competitors to sell their products

                  • D
                  • AnonD-99764
                  • m%}
                  • 13 Mar 2013

                  AnonD-85611, 12 Mar 2013Looks like Sony is the worst manufacturer when we are talki... moreTrue. They have to:
                  1) Increase screen quality
                  2) Increase sound quality
                  3) Make better cameras (I mean that 13MP is good, but that's about it)
                  4) Use the latest processors. It's so lame that 1 month after the release of Xperia Z, Snapdragon 600 comes out (inside some of the devices, like G Pro or HTC One). And then 800 and NVidia Tegra 4.

                    • D
                    • AnonD-99764
                    • m%}
                    • 12 Mar 2013

                    Nice review! Though the real competition is still ahead for Xperia Z. Unfortunately it uses a little outdated processor, so I only hope that its design, build quality and water resistance are going to play some role.

                      • ?
                      • Anonymous
                      • nIh
                      • 12 Mar 2013

                      Xperia Z sucks. Xperia ZL rulez! (More compact and ergonomic, more durable material, likely better loudspeaker, IR blaster).

                        • ?
                        • Anonymous
                        • KI6
                        • 12 Mar 2013

                        lucian, 12 Mar 2013Of course in benchmarks htc will always be a little slower ... moreDude are you blind? they both are using the same chipsets! who cares who introduces the same thing first as long as they are the SAME?! Its how you integrate the chip to work and by far what i see Sony has done an excellent job in integrating the chip!

                          • D
                          • AnonD-82297
                          • p2L
                          • 12 Mar 2013

                          Xperia Z is the clear winner

                            • M
                            • McKnully
                            • mKY
                            • 12 Mar 2013

                            HTC's video appears sharper because of more aggressive image sharpening.... Yeah right GSMarena.
                            It appears sharper but yet it lacks in so much details compared to the Xperia Z.
                            Just look at the branches and grass to your left.
                            With HTC, it appears blocky while you clearly distinguish what is what in the Xperia Z.

                              • D
                              • AnonD-86903
                              • pTe
                              • 12 Mar 2013

                              definitely my XZ wins.
                              HTC must bring its ONE to compete with Z
                              and of course the daily interest on the main page will tell you who is the real winner.

                                • ?
                                • Anonymous
                                • YcX
                                • 12 Mar 2013

                                AnonD-109426, 12 Mar 2013And the next is the s4 which will come to dominate and rule... moreS4 is a piece of shit and Samsung is a piece of shit.

                                HTC all the way.

                                  • l
                                  • lucian
                                  • nDB
                                  • 12 Mar 2013

                                  Of course in benchmarks htc will always be a little slower because they are the Firsts to introduce new tech,so,after a half a year,or a year some other producer comes with "something faster".htc is still the king of smartphones,and let's not forget is water proof also(not like xperia,but it is certified) and will get the new Sense 5 soon.

                                    • D
                                    • AnonD-85611
                                    • L4D
                                    • 12 Mar 2013

                                    Looks like Sony is the worst manufacturer when we are talking about screens, it's unbelievable, even LG and HTC is light years ahead in terms of contrast and viewing angles.

                                      • D
                                      • AnonD-109426
                                      • fuN
                                      • 12 Mar 2013

                                      And the next is the s4 which will come to dominate and rule them all

                                        • ?
                                        • Anonymous
                                        • v0X
                                        • 12 Mar 2013

                                        nah...htc always releases a refreshed version of its flagship every 3 months