German court denies Apple Galaxy Tab 10.1N injunction

23 December, 2011
According to the court's assessment, Samsung moved away sufficiently from the legally protected design.

Sort by:

  • ?
  • Anonymous
  • 49t
  • 23 Dec 2011

Anonymous, 23 Dec 2011I guess most of the previous comments here about the game c... moreUsing iPod and iPad as pioneers while disregarding Samnsun'g technology as 'just another product' doesnt float well. You are implying that iPod was the first mp3 player and iPad was the first tablet which is wrong on both instances.

Now you might argue that iPods and iPads made the mp3 player and tablets more famous and attracted the consumers because they made it better. And I will agree with you on that point. So how is Samsung's amoled or any other technology trying to make the current smartphones/tablets not a better outcome for the consumers?

I am not a apple or samsung or any other company fanboy but rather I am just a consumer who likes to see the best products. Its people like you who demean other companies just to prove that the company you like is better is what causing the consumer outrage. Same goes for Samsung fans, just because you like Samsung doesnt mean Apple has no good products.

    • o
    • oldie
    • 0Ur
    • 23 Dec 2011

    Anonymous, 23 Dec 2011FYI, Apple design and develop A5 chip. Samsung just manufac... moreIt's the stupidest thing I've ever heard. It's like telling the car manufacturer to make u a car with xxx HP, to look like that, etc, and after that to claim that you manufactured the car.

      • c
      • courage will will
      • MY4
      • 23 Dec 2011

      It seems Apple currently having losing market fever with samsung and other competitiors, which leads to file a lawsuits againts samsung.

        • ?
        • Anonymous
        • vV5
        • 23 Dec 2011

        Anonymous, 23 Dec 2011Apple seems to like the A5 chips that Samsung develops for them.FYI, Apple design and develop A5 chip. Samsung just manufactured it. you better research before you post so you don't look ignorant.

          • ?
          • Anonymous
          • kIa
          • 23 Dec 2011

          Anonymous, 23 Dec 2011You just admitted to yourself that Samsung is more of copyi... moreApple seems to like the A5 chips that Samsung develops for them.

            • ?
            • Anonymous
            • vV5
            • 23 Dec 2011

            I guess most of the previous comments here about the game changer didn't know what they talking about. As you cited example about the Galaxy S2, what is the impact of Galaxy S2 in the mobile market segment? Does it leads to something for what we are today? Nothing...it's not even close to the sales of the previous iPhones. Heck, it's not even the first to have a dual core smartphones. It's not the most superb display in terms of resolution when it was released.

            To give you some real game changer in terms of technology? look back on the iPods, it kills CD's, change the music industry, look back on the iTunes Store, look at iPad 1, and look at what we are now. Look at Olympus when they release mirrorless dSLR, and look at how major manufacturers such as Sony, Nikon, Samsung follows the path. Then tell me, what Samsung Mobile division did pioneer in the mobile industry that are setting the pace of the technology?

              • ?
              • Anonymous
              • vV5
              • 23 Dec 2011

              knightstalker, 23 Dec 2011You serious? LED/Super AMOLED/Exynos/bringing loads of goo... moreSamsung didn't pioneer the LED technology and AMOLEDs are subjective and not giving you realistic colors, that's why professional photographer don't prefer AMOLED display. They didn't develop WiFi direct, and touchwiz? another copycat...and Galaxy S2? mehh, overhyped device, GS2 as game changer? not even close. I can count 10 devices around me right here right now, only 2 using Samsung, around 6 is iPhone and the remaining is from different brand. Is that a game changer?

                • n
                • natsu
                • t7Q
                • 23 Dec 2011

                samsung supplies the hardware for crapple. and now, this is what they get in return?

                  • p
                  • ph00ny
                  • QPs
                  • 23 Dec 2011

                  Anonymous, 23 Dec 2011You just admitted to yourself that Samsung is more of copyi... moreThat's because they set real technology standards in things such as 3G transmission methods, power management, etc while building variety of components using state of the art manufacturing method. Why do you think apple keeps going back to them for more parts despite the legal issues?

                    • M
                    • MUFTAH
                    • fwh
                    • 23 Dec 2011

                    thanks your action satisfy me ve ry ee

                      • S
                      • Skeptical Human
                      • IV}
                      • 23 Dec 2011

                      htc, y u no sue samsung for flyer alike!?!?!?!?

                        • D
                        • AnonD-5197
                        • qbY
                        • 23 Dec 2011

                        Anonymous, 23 Dec 2011You just admitted to yourself that Samsung is more of copyi... moreTheir AMOLED displays are definitely game changers. I guess you haven't seen much technology in general.

                          • A
                          • Alex
                          • LaC
                          • 23 Dec 2011

                          Damn... Apple should win this!

                            • M
                            • Max
                            • t}B
                            • 23 Dec 2011

                            Anonymous, 23 Dec 2011You just admitted to yourself that Samsung is more of copyi... moreGame Changer????? probably you a new kid in the town or probably you dont know what is the meaning of Game Changer..... Have you ever heared of Samsung Galaxy S2 or lets say even Galaxy Note????

                              • ?
                              • Anonymous
                              • IWQ
                              • 23 Dec 2011

                              Maybe anything that looks rectangular, they will sue.

                                • R
                                • Ramit
                                • vG6
                                • 23 Dec 2011

                                Anonymous, 23 Dec 2011You just admitted to yourself that Samsung is more of copyi... moreever heard what super amoled is ?

                                  • k
                                  • knightstalker
                                  • nsD
                                  • 23 Dec 2011

                                  Anonymous, 23 Dec 2011You just admitted to yourself that Samsung is more of copyi... moreYou serious?
                                  LED/Super AMOLED/Exynos/bringing loads of goodies like WiFi Direct via TouchWiz 4/Hell,Galaxy S II was a game changer as well...
                                  Your statement is flawed.

                                    • S
                                    • SL
                                    • IV8
                                    • 23 Dec 2011

                                    apple will dissapear another 3 years

                                      • j
                                      • johnnydepp15
                                      • vGF
                                      • 23 Dec 2011

                                      first crapple losing share in europian market & now this.
                                      Beginning of the end.

                                        • ?
                                        • Anonymous
                                        • pJc
                                        • 23 Dec 2011

                                        Tarek, 23 Dec 2011Like I said a few weeks ago, a friend of mine, who works in... moreI find it hard to believe that your mate would tell you such thing. Either his or she is bullshxting or not your friend at all.