HTC Butterfly S review: Evolution complete

Evolution complete

GSMArena team, 21 August 2013.

Google Now

As an integral part of Android Jelly Bean, Google Now is available on the HTC Butterfly S. In addition to being able to recognize voice commands, Google Now will learn from your usage patterns, and display relevant information. For example, if you search for a particular sports team frequently, Google Now will serve information for upcoming games you might want to watch.

HTC Butterfly S review HTC Butterfly S review
Google Now

The service interacts with you by generating cards which are displayed on your screen and give you a short overview of information it believes is relevant to you. Going to work in the morning? Google Now knows this and lets you know there's a big traffic jam on your usual way to the office, and will offer you a re-route. This extends to a multitude of other areas, including weather, traffic, public transit stations, and nearby points of interest.

HTC Butterfly S review HTC Butterfly S review
Google Now

You can either type or talk to Google Now and the app will give you one of its aforementioned info cards (if available) and read you its contents aloud (you can disable this in the app settings). If there's no card to help with the answer to your question, Google Now will simply initiate a Google web search instead.

There is also a Google Now widget which generates information for you based on what your interests are. You can put it on the lockscreen for at-a-glance info.

HTC Butterfly S review
Google Now widgets

Phonebook offers a full array of features

The People app in Sense 5 has seen some minor changes too. Instead of clickable tabs at the bottom of the screen you get side-scrollable tabs at the top, which is a more convenient solution (and along the lines of stock Android).

You get the dialer, all contacts, groups (including favorite contacts there), as well as a call log. Once again, you can reorder tabs and remove the ones that you don't need (Groups or Call history).

From a drop-down menu at the top, you can filter contacts based on where they came from - the phone's address book, Facebook, Twitter or your HTC Sense account. If an account has multiple subgroups (e.g. Gmail's groups), they can be toggled individually as well by tapping the ellipsis button.

HTC Butterfly S review HTC Butterfly S review HTC Butterfly S review
The phonebook

Selecting a contact displays the basic details: name and photo, numbers, emails and such. That's just the first tab - the other tabs hold further details and means of communication, including email and a call log.

HTC Butterfly S review HTC Butterfly S review HTC Butterfly S review
Viewing a contact

The second tab holds the texts, emails and call history between you and the contact. The next one displays social networking contact updates, and finally the "Gallery" pulls the albums that contacts have created on Flickr and Facebook. These tabs can be hidden and rearranged too.

HTC Butterfly S review
Contact social network albums

When editing a contact, you start off with just one of the main fields but you can easily add more. If a contact is linked with a Facebook or other account you can see them either merged or choose to view either profile. In fact, the phone will automatically suggest to do that when it thinks two entries are for the same person.

HTC Butterfly S review HTC Butterfly S review
Editing a contact

A handy option is Block contact - the Butterfly S will block all calls, texts and other messages from that contact. You can add any number too, which is great if you get spam messages from an automatic number. You can later check the call and message history from those contacts and take them out of the dog house if you like.

Telephony works like a charm

The HTC Butterfly S did great in our signal test, providing great reception in environments where others dropped calls. The volume in the earpiece was extremely loud (we almost never used it at full volume) while clarity wasn't an issue.

The dialer on the HTC Butterfly S displays your recent calls with the usual tabs above, accessible via side-swipes. There's smart dialing on the Butterfly S - once you start typing on the keyboard, contacts will be filtered by name or by phone number. You can even switch to a QWERTY keyboard instead of the phone keypad. Another nice feature is the button that unveils all the contact info and lets you do just about anything - send an email, assign a custom ringtone and so on. It's a handy way to find the right contact and do more than just call them.

HTC Butterfly S review HTC Butterfly S review HTC Butterfly S review
The dialer

The only problem we have with the smart dial is that it only suggests one contact at a time - if you want another one (e.g. both Dexter and Dee Dee match "de" or "33"), you have to keep typing until you find the right one, you can't just pick out of a list of 3-4 matching contacts as on most other phones.

Yet another option is voice dialing, you hit the button, wait a couple of seconds for the Butterfly S to get ready and say "Call Dexter". This is a little too slow for our liking though (the phone says "Just one moment", pauses, "Say a command when you're ready" and then you can talk).

The HTC Butterfly S doesn't support video calling over the cellular network by default. The good news is there are a bunch of apps which could fill in the blank spot with video calling over Wi-Fi and 3G.

HTC Butterfly S review
In-call screen

The handset packs the standard set of accelerometer-based tricks - turning the phone in the middle of a call will enable the loudspeaker, Quiet ring on pickup will reduce the loudness of the ringtone when you move the phone and Pocket mode boosts ringtone volume if the phone is in your pocket or purse.

The focus of BoomSound speakers is not absolute loudness but the quality of the sound. Somewhat surprisingly, the loudspeaker on the HTC Butterfly S did not perform as well as other recent HTC devices, like the One, or even the original Butterfly. It scored a Below Average mark, which means you'll have a hard time hearing it in loud environments or from inside a bag or pocket.

Speakerphone testVoice, dBPink noise/ Music, dBRinging phone, dBOveral score
Sony Xperia Z60.1 58.361.6Below Average
Apple iPhone 566.866.167.7Below Average
Nokia Lumia 92061.6 64.865.8Below Average
HTC Butterfly S66.7 61.972.2Below Average
Samsung Galaxy S4 mini66.3 64.875.1Average
HTC Butterfly69.0 70.777.9Good
HTC One69.3 66.675.9Good
HTC One mini68.0 68.778.1Good<
Samsung I9505 Galaxy S470.6 66.277.3Good
Samsung Galaxy S4 Active72.7 66.678.1Good
LG Optimus G74.671.382.7Excellent

Messaging well set

Android and the HTC Butterfly S are capable of handling all sorts of messages - SMS, MMS, email. Social networking is covered by several apps and widgets, and there's Hangouts, which can connect you to Google's chat network.

SMS and MMS messages are displayed in threads - you see a list of all conversations, each one is listed with the contact's photo, name and the subject of the last message, as well as a part of the actual message (you can choose 1, 2 or 3 preview lines). Tapping a conversation brings up the entire message history with that contact.

To add recipients, just start typing a name or number and choose from the contacts offered. The compose box covers about a fifth of the screen in portrait mode or half in landscape.

HTC Butterfly S review HTC Butterfly S review

The keyboard is pretty nice. Keys are well spaced but the overlay doesn't include any gaps between them, which is only a cosmetic feature and poses no discomfort. The 5" diagonal offers ample space for comfortable typing. Some keys can be long pressed to get additional symbols, which speeds up typing in some cases as you don't have to keep going back to the symbols section of the keyboard.

A tap-and-hold on the text box gives you access to functions such as cut, copy and paste. You are free to paste the copied text across applications like email, notes, chats, etc. and vice versa. You can also enable arrow keys, which show up below the portrait keyboard (but not the landscape one).

Predictive input is available, the software will even try to guess the next word you're about to type. When the phone has learned from you, it can get pretty good at guessing. You can edit a personal dictionary of words and backup and restore it either to local storage or to an email account.

HTC has included the Trace keyboard, which acts like Swype. You drag a finger over the desired keys and the phone predicts what you're trying to write. It works really well but language support is limited. Voice transcription is also available.

HTC Butterfly S review HTC Butterfly S review HTC Butterfly S review
QWERTY keyboard comes with Trace

Converting SMS into MMS is as simple as adding some multimedia content to the message. You can just add a photo or an audio file to go with the text, or you can get creative with several slides and photos.

The HTC Butterfly S comes with two email apps - the traditional Gmail app and the built-in HTC Mail app, which merges all your email accounts into a single interface.

The Gmail client has the trademark conversation style view and can manage multiple Gmail accounts. Batch operations are supported too, in case you need to handle email messages in bulk.

HTC Butterfly S HTC Butterfly S HTC Butterfly S HTC Butterfly S

The HTC Mail app features conversation view in an attempt to mimic the original Gmail client's threaded view, which is otherwise missing in the generic inbox. Emails in a thread are grouped and a number of emails and a down arrow appear - tap the arrow to show/hide the messages in that group.

You can add multiple accounts (from multiple services) and view them individually or in a combined inbox. Each account is color-coded, so you can quickly associate each message with its relevant account.

HTC Butterfly S review HTC Butterfly S review
Sense Mail app

The Mail app has tabs like many other Sense 5 apps. You can choose the Filters setting and show/hide the ones you want or rearrange the visible ones. You can choose from All, Favorites, Unread and Attached (hidden by default).

Email sorting is enabled (in either ascending or descending order) by date, subject, sender, priority and size. The currently applied filter is displayed in the top right corner of the display.

There's hardly anything we can think of that the HTC Butterfly S lacks in terms of email capabilities. The settings for popular email services are automatically configured. POP/IMAP accounts and Active Sync accounts are supported.

Reader comments

  • Iejaz

wi fi password

  • AnonD-112678

The audio quality review is misleading as it does not test output voltage. When I first bought this phone I noticed a nasty bass distortion when I was listening to "Touch" by Daft Punk at volumes above 11/15. Since Android 4.3 it's fine at 12/15 but ...

  • NameNick

I've had this phone for a month now and it's not bad. Battery life is above average, display's quite nice and it does everything well (I haven't bothered with the camera - I have a Nokia 808 for that). But as a phone ? It IS a bit too big - not lea...