LG Optimus 3D P920
- p
- pH1
- xKw
- 16 Feb 2011
Mobilemaster, 16 Feb 2011Hi!
You posted a very interesting comment. Which is the ne... moreu have a few mistakes or omissions in ur comment.
while ur correct about screen size for all 3 u dont mention dpi or ppi which is where atrix wins. its more more pixels packed closely together. it will make images appear less pixelated. so while samsung might be more colorful and lg has 3d, doing certain stuff like read small print might be better on atrix.
u said u think atrix has best cpu, but it does worse on benchmarks (maybe bcos of the higher resolution which probably makes it slower). a smaller resolution doesnt need as much cpu power so it performs better. thats y the se x10 minis did considerably better than some other android with similarly clocked cpus. here is a link another user had posted:
http://www.engadget.com/2011/02/15/lg-optimus-3ds-omap-4-benchmarked-pulls-ahead-of-exynos-and-te/
the optimus 3d does the best. my guess is the dual channel feature improved performance slightly compared to the others. the atrix did much worse and fell behind sgs2.
"In terms of camera the SG2 is the winner, because it has a better camera."
--> that depends a lot on ur taste. dont just go with mp count. o3d can also take pictures and video in 3d - a first for phones and it can also record 1080p like the sgs2. the specs say that 03d records 1080p at less fps than sgs2 but some samsung phones record duplicate frames sometimes so while its true that they record 30fps, they dont record 30 different fps. video quality on both need to be compared fairly when they r both released. correct me if im wrong but i think lg had the first phone to record at 120 fps for slo mo replay at 15fps. also on the subject, o3d probably has hdmi mirroring (like 2x) which is great for connecting the handset to an external monitor, and not just for video but also for games. sgs2 doesnt hv hdmi and even if there is a way to connect it to ur tv, it doesnt list 1080p or even 720p playback in its specs. so while its debatable which is better at recording content, lg is better at playing back the content.
"If we talk about the OS version, the SG 2 has the latest version, and the LG and the Atrix has the Froyo, so you have to update your phone which is a disadvantage."
--> i agree but going back to those cpu results, this means atrix might do better than sgs2 and both lg 2x and 3d shud do much better than sgs2 when the update comes bcos the performance of handsets was improved with android 2.3.
pHone
- ?
- Anonymous
- mh$
- 16 Feb 2011
Woudl like it with smaller screen. Or with that one too, if it's cheap and really for use :P
- ?
- Anonymous
- MSR
- 16 Feb 2011
The Samsung Galaxy S2 does have HDMI but via the USB as the phone is the first phone to have MHL. Go to youtube and type Mobile High Definition Link.
- M
- Mobilemaster
- La5
- 16 Feb 2011
Bibot, 16 Feb 2011the question now here is...
who's now the best?
-Samsung ... moreHi!
You posted a very interesting comment. Which is the new smart phone king? Let's compare the phones. The GS2 has a 4.3 inch SAMOLED Plus display. The Atrix has a TFT screen(which is not as good like Samsung's screen). The LG has a 3D LCD screen(with it's 3D capabilities can attract MANY people, but not every one!) We all know that 3D in mobiles is a new technology. The SG2 and the LG Optimus 3D have 4.3 inches, the Atrix is left behind in this category.
Now let's talk about the CPU, which is VERY important for a lot of people! All the 3 devices have 1GHZ Dual Core CPU's, but the Samsung has their own CPU, the Orion. Now what is the best, their own CPU, or the famous Nvidia Tegra? I think that the winner is the Atrix here! :) Now about the Ram. The Atrix and the SG2 have 1 GB of Ram, and the LG Optimus 3D has half of Ram. The Atrix and the SG2 are the winners here.
If we talk about the internal storage, the SG 2 is the WINNER! In terms of camera the SG2 is the winner, because it has a better camera. If we talk about the OS version, the SG 2 has the latest version, and the LG and the Atrix has the Froyo, so you have to update your phone which is a disadvantage.
Now you choose. If you want a phone with a BIG and clear display and if you want a phone with a big internal storage(32 GB), the SG2 is 4 you! :)
If you want a special phone, the LG Optimus 3D is 4 you! :)
If you want a phone with great CPU and if you want a biometric fingerprint sensor phone the Atrix is 4 you! :)
I hope this helps you.
- D
- AnonD-37
- q{6
- 16 Feb 2011
Bibot, 16 Feb 2011the question now here is...
who's now the best?
-Samsung ... moreRead the article on the link below and see for yourself.
http://www.engadget.com/2011/02/15/lg-optimus-3ds-omap-4-benchmarked-pulls-ahead-of-exynos-and-te/
- B
- Bibot
- t7P
- 16 Feb 2011
the question now here is...
who's now the best?
-Samsung GS2
-Motorola Atrix
-LG optimus 3D
or do we have to wait for iphone 5?
- A
- Angry jeffrey
- 39B
- 16 Feb 2011
I never knew that superamoled screens can suffer a screen burn like plasmas, i work in mobile store so i know what im talking about, consider this when you buy a new phone.
- D
- AnonD-37
- q{6
- 16 Feb 2011
Ben, 16 Feb 2011Duel 5mp camera, LG have serious given the other companies ... moreIt might take the competition 6 months to get something similar out of the door. LG O3D is just too revolutionary to take a pass.
- B
- Ben
- uMJ
- 16 Feb 2011
Duel 5mp camera, LG have serious given the other companies a run for their money with the 2X, 3d and black, I'd like to see the other companies rise to the occasion.
- v
- vassbak
- S7R
- 16 Feb 2011
I preffer Samsung Galaxy S II,it is better!
- ?
- Anonymous
- kxA
- 16 Feb 2011
rohan, 15 Feb 2011Not necessarily coz galaxy s 2 has 1gb of ram,8mp camera, s... moreYes to everything you say about the samsung however, it don't do 3D so yes it have one major "UP" on the Galaxy s. There are many phones that have that super AMOLED screen but non can say they have a 3D, or can record in 3D. So that my friend makes it a slight edge.
- ?
- Anonymous
- IV8
- 16 Feb 2011
I almost swear to my self to get Samsung Galaxy II to replace my omnia 2, but until i saw LG 3D.
I can see the 3D effect on gsmarena fish test video when they pause and move the phone…
Wow LG, your phone so good… Bring it on…
- g
- guest
- KeY
- 16 Feb 2011
rohan, 15 Feb 2011Not necessarily coz galaxy s 2 has 1gb of ram,8mp camera, s... moregalaxy s2 has no hdmi port, that is a deal breaker.
- S
- SEFanX10i
- 2S$
- 16 Feb 2011
It has 4Gb (Giga bits) memory = 512 MB (Megabytes)
Not 4 gigabytes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- D
- AnonD-37
- q{6
- 16 Feb 2011
Adel_m, 16 Feb 2011Look at this compare:
galaxy s II:
{125.3/66.1/8.49
116g... moreTI OMAP 4430 > Tegra 2> Exynos 4210
Hardware wise, O3D beats SGS II. Galaxy S II is cool and has advanced hardware wise but there is nothing really groundbreaking. It's more of an evolutionary product but the O3D is revolutionary with its 3D screen. It may look gimicky right now but I think it will be a hit.
O3D is on a league of it's own and a more closer comparison will be SGS II vs LG Optimus 2x. However, when it comes to pure processing power, the LG O2X is still better than SGS II.
The Optimus 3D is my next phone.
http://www.engadget.com/2011/02/15/lg-optimus-3ds-omap-4-benchmarked-pulls-ahead-of-exynos-and-te/
- n
- nel
- t7x
- 16 Feb 2011
almost perfect was expecting 3d pictures also. maybe i'll wait for the next 3d phone video and photo and video as ringtone
- p
- pH1
- xKw
- 16 Feb 2011
Adel_m, 16 Feb 2011Look at this compare:
galaxy s II:
{125.3/66.1/8.49
116g... morehow cud u say samsung is better? it shud be a tie if not a win for lg.
compare:
-SCREEN: (tie)
same size, same resolution. lg has 3d but s2 has super amoled+ which doesnt look as good outdoors under sunlight.
-RAM & CPU:
whether or not lg has 4gb ram or not im not gna debate. both hv 1 ghz dual core cpu. lg uses dual channel tho and samsung does not so lg shud be faster even if it has less ram. also some galaxy phones slow down for random reasons. also the lg 2x did better on benchmarks than samsung s2 and lg 3d is even better bcos of the dual channel thing. it will be a lot better when it get android 2.3.
http://www.anandtech.com/Show/Index/4177?cPage=2&all=False&sort=0&page=1&slug=samsungs-galaxy-s-ii-preliminary-performance-mali400-benchmarked
-CAMERA:
being able to shoot in 3d is better than 2d. while samsung does claim 30fps, they hv a tendency to shoot duplicated frames, which does not make the video smoother and quality sometimes worsens. 3d pictures r better than 2d. i can get a rly good 2d picture with most cameras, however, not many of them capture 3d pictures. so this can truly replace a camera. besides, 1080p is only 2mp so the quality matters more than the mp count. just look at htc 8mp cameras. they r not better than all 5mp cams.
-EXTRAS
samsung has bigger battery (but we dont know which has longer battery life), swype input, a gorilla glass display, more internal memory (but sd cards supported on both so this is not too important)
lg has hdmi (and hdmi mirroring). s2 doesnt hv hdmi for some reason and this is surprising given the list of v good specs it has. lg has agreement with youtube 3d, and 3d playback. samsung doesnt hv 1080p nor 720p playback even in 2d. which might make sense since it doesnt hv hdmi. also lg 3d comes preloaded with 3d games and there will be a few games that r 3d and hence will only work on lg 3d.
i just dont c how the s2 is a better phone.
pHone
- A
- Adel_m
- 39E
- 16 Feb 2011
Look at this compare:
galaxy s II:
{125.3/66.1/8.49
116g
super led plus (the best on the world)
32GB internal
1GB Ram
8MP face and smil detection & SECONDARY 2MP & 1080p@(30fps)
usb:on to go
bluetooth: v3 + HS
1650mAh
COOOOOOOL design}
optimus 3D:
{128.8/68/11.9
168g
3D lcd
8GB internal
512mB Ram
2D:[5MP & 1080p@(24fps)] , 3D:[2MP & 720p@(30fps)] & SECONDARY 1.3MP(is not 3D)
bluetooth: v3 (it's like v2.1)
HDMI port
1500mAh}
i prefer galaxy s II, it's really better.
- s
- sugacious
- v0e
- 16 Feb 2011
this is the cooooooooooolest phone i've ever seen
way to go LG! u did a damn good job.
- O
- OneEyed
- 0xf
- 15 Feb 2011
Mario, 15 Feb 2011Can this phone record 3D videos or 3D stills while holding ... moreCan you still see 3D when turning your head sideways?