LG and Samsung yet to decide on the Gingerbread upgrade for Optimus One and Galaxy S

9 December, 2010
Android v2.3 Gingerbread is out and the update mess has returned once again. LG was the first to confuse its users about the update, while Samsung is yet to decide the fate...

Sort by:

  • G
  • Galaxy S user
  • Lca
  • 16 Dec 2010

"Samsung feels the same way about its best-selling Galaxy S lineup. The company will wait for the official requirements, will do some research how it will affect the overall performance and experience and then will decide to update or not"...

Yey...so they build Nexus S and don't know about the "official requirements", or "how it will affect the overall performance and experience" to decide...

NO COMMENT AT ALL!!!

    • r
    • rd0311
    • Inn
    • 11 Dec 2010

    I wish that someone would find out in fact that goggle is behind the galaxy s phones not getting gingerbread. This would be the last android powered phone I ever buy.

      • i
      • iphoned4u2thenme2u
      • P@x
      • 11 Dec 2010

      Anonymous, 10 Dec 2010if you have iPhone you won't have this problem; samsung suk... moreVery true, we like
      that talk

      *posted from the iphone4 squeezing the bumper case hard into the antenna joint to prove any signal issue talk is all lies.

        • r
        • ritzbitz
        • j07
        • 11 Dec 2010

        ok guys, two things, Samsung is not the Red Cross (neither is LG), they are a business, they exist to make money, the more the better. Now to get to the topic, I have froyo on my SGS yeah it was a month longer than I would have liked but hey i got it (those of you who don't have it yet blame your dumb providers not samsung...) Ideally I would love to get Gingerbread also but since there is a new model of the sgs (nexus 2) available soon this model is not likely to get many more updates, if it does get gingerbread expect it to be after the nexus 2 has atleast 2 months of sales behind since that would least affect its sales(ALTHOUGH*** if Nexus 2 is not a global launch expect Gingerbread for sure on the sgs since it would boost sales in countries that aren't getting the nexus 2), the best approach is of course rooting your phone and getting what ever you want, anyways froyo is great and I got my sgs new for 100$ so I will probably upgrade soon anyways...

          • ?
          • Anonymous
          • j{1
          • 11 Dec 2010

          shiva, 10 Dec 2010s but samsung must go for the update to galaxy s because if... more
          google made a deal with samsung, to not update the galaxy s to 2.3 and google will make huge profits from the nexus s because of the fact that is has the latest version and therefore by google making profit samsung will also gain profit because this means selling more samsung units!

          So screw the old customers, it's all about money. Now I know for sure that even with Nokia's flaws but they are much cleaner than samsung's dirty policy. At least most of us know that nokia always update their devices.

            • s
            • shiva
            • utd
            • 10 Dec 2010

            Anonymous, 10 Dec 2010This is the dilemma on Samsung's part. If they going to giv... mores but samsung must go for the update to galaxy s because if they don give a update then no one trust samsung after this so it will effect overall sale of samsung in future so they should not mind abt nexus s sale.....

            but the true fact is wat we all do is once the new phones arrives samsung will be the best in specifications part so ppl fall on samsung as i was doing all time even when i struggled lot with omnia update i got this galaxy y ? because of specification......

              • ?
              • Anonymous
              • 4d{
              • 10 Dec 2010

              chrishd3z, 10 Dec 2010As much as I love Android this is one of the problems that ... moreif you have iPhone you won't have this problem; samsung suk n Apple rules the world.

                • ?
                • Anonymous
                • t7K
                • 10 Dec 2010

                This is the dilemma on Samsung's part. If they going to give the Galaxy S with a Gingerbread update it will surely going to effect Nexus S' sale.

                  • A
                  • Adam
                  • j{1
                  • 10 Dec 2010


                  Well I must agree with some of the guys here that google are also to be blamed because of their rushed policy in releasing versions and updates like crazy and therefore some manufactures will find it a little hard to keep up with such updates. Specially samsung which are widely known for their terrible support and update after sales.

                  So yes even though I'm not an apple fan, but getting an iphone means you will get updates for 2-3 years ahead! Which is a big advantage in my opinion, however, and please focus on however, you must keep in mind that android updates are far stronger than apple. Seriously there is no major changes in the iphones updates, they are just minor.

                  So no ones perfect, in the end it all comes to your personal taste and preferences.

                    • C
                    • Cambodia Sgs
                    • PWa
                    • 10 Dec 2010

                    Alui, 10 Dec 2010I just cannot understand why Samsung did not release the up... moreDid You get the latest kies?

                    I, my self in small country cambodia even get the froyo from samsung through kies..
                    But I had to work hard to get the latest kies version to get official froyo...

                      • c
                      • chrishd3z
                      • kAx
                      • 10 Dec 2010

                      As much as I love Android this is one of the problems that stops me from purchasing an Android phone, especially one made by Samsung which hardly ever updates it's firmware in order to push consumers to purchase a new line up. My last google Android phone was the Nexus One and I'm thankful for it. Updates are ported to the Nexus One at a timely fashion without having me to worry that I am stuck for months/life with a phone that wont receive coming updates. I really wanted to purchase the Nexus 2 but the fact that Samsung and not HTC is the manufacture only stops me from making such purchase. Samsung sucks and continue's to build products made to break (plastic covering). I have since jumped into Apple's iphone 4 and I'm glad to know that my OS won't stay behind because updates are automatically available to me.
                      Although I may be an iphone 4 user at the time I really wish to jump back into Android, but these devices are just not giving me the security I need to make my decision. HTC is the only Android Manufacture that gives me confidence and it is such manufacture that will enable me to jump back to Android when they release a product with the spec's, "quality hardware" , and updated OS of my liking.

                      The Nexus One, Desire HD (Evo 4g), and the Desire Z (t-mobile G2) are all made by HTC and show's what a true phone should be.

                        • ?
                        • Anonymous
                        • A99
                        • 10 Dec 2010

                        Blah, gotta wait until January until FROYO on the Galaxy S for Orange in the UK.

                          • A
                          • Al
                          • xC5
                          • 10 Dec 2010

                          Neogeo, 10 Dec 2010If buying a new handset every two years seem too much for y... more"If buying a new handset every two years seem too much for you."
                          Where did I say that? I said a manufacturer should offer two years of updates because most of the people have two-years-contract and will get disappointed otherwise and change the phone manufacturer.

                          "I'm using a 3GS now which is a year plus device and I can still run every game/apps in the market. Can you said the same for your 1 years plus Android device that running on a same 600 mhz CPU?"
                          My phone has a 1GHz processor and is less than one-year-old because I change about every eighteen months my phone. I am far from being your son and I probably am older than you are. Mine also runs any application from the Android Market.


                          "Just look at HTC Hero, the manufacturer already abandon it and it had not even make it past two years. "
                          This phone came with Android 1.5 and is now running Android 2.1 so two major updates. What I like with iphone-lovers is they always forget the community : you can get Android 2.2 for your HTC hero... independently from HTC.

                            • j
                            • jjsoviet
                            • qJm
                            • 10 Dec 2010

                            You guys don't know how capable Android developers can be. If official support is a dud, turn to the community for the update. I've seen non-Gingerbread devices getting the 2.3 treatment thanks to XDA Developers.

                              • A
                              • Al
                              • xC5
                              • 10 Dec 2010

                              Neogeo, 10 Dec 2010iPhone 3G release July 2008, 2 and a half year ago. It's up... more"iPhone 3G release July 2008, 2 and a half year ago. It's upgradeable to the later iOS and doing ok for the majority of game on the market except a few graphic hoe game like infinity blade. So there's goes your theory of iPhone 4 not getting update 2 years later."
                              iOS4 appears in june 2010 so the iPhone 3G was 2-years-and-a-month-old that is completely different from my 2 years, you are right. I will agree with you if and only if the iPhone 3G updates to iOS5 (and I don't think it will unlike you). Let's talk about it in june next year ;-)

                                • A
                                • Al
                                • xC5
                                • 10 Dec 2010

                                Anonymous, 10 Dec 2010Old iphones (2007) has 400mhz cpu and 128mb ram, while ipho... more"Old iphones (2007) has 400mhz cpu and 128mb ram, while iphone 4 (2010) has 1ghz a4 cpu integrated with graphic accelerator and 512mb ram.
                                3 years later phones wont be 3ghz cpu and 3gb ram...
                                So 1ghz cpu and 512mb hardware enough powerful for at least 2-3 year ios updates..."
                                And so? I said two years... Moreover compare a mono-core processor with a multi-core one and you have your answer.

                                  • ?
                                  • Anonymous
                                  • u1J
                                  • 10 Dec 2010

                                  Anonymous, 10 Dec 2010LOLZ Samsung India, samsung India hasn't update froyo ye... moreSamsung India rolled out FroYo for Galaxy almost 3 weeks ago.. I am a proud and happy HTC Desire owner!

                                    • ?
                                    • Anonymous
                                    • vGx
                                    • 10 Dec 2010

                                    Anonymous, 10 Dec 2010its not always a bad thing staying with an older os version... moretrue. but atleast the update is available, its our will to update or not i even downgraded my ipod touch 2g but you always have choice. but with samsung i think i got froyo for sgs i am lucky

                                      • A
                                      • Alui
                                      • Am9
                                      • 10 Dec 2010

                                      Anonymous, 10 Dec 2010During that time, running Froyo 2.2.1 on my SGS happily des... moreI just cannot understand why Samsung did not release the update to ALL the Samsung Galaxy S owners. Did you get Froyo on yours from Samsung or from Odin:)?. I do not understand why Samsung is holding back the Froyo update for all users. I have Froyo on mine, from ODIN, my wife still waits for the official Samsung update. Our next phones will be a future generation of iPhones.

                                        • ?
                                        • Anonymous
                                        • M3s
                                        • 10 Dec 2010

                                        its not always a bad thing staying with an older os version take iphone for example the new updates are rubbish on 3g id rather have an older os thats works well than one with extra stuff that is slow and doesnt work well