Apple will fight Right to Repair legislature

15 February 2017
Apple will fight Right to Repair, the US proposed-bill that will require makers to sell parts and disclose service manuals to third party repair shops and consumers.

Sort by:

While those companies are willing to be Liberal gods, they show what they are really made of when Money is at stake!

    • D
    • AnonD-4254
    • XNw
    • 17 Feb 2017

    See, they should issue good repair manuals with safety instructions. Then why should an incident occur?
    Plus, companies always have the defence of voiding the warranty if the phone is not serviced at its so called "authorised" place, so what's wrong about passing the bill anyhow?

    Its all about money. These companies charge hellish money to repair just to add profits, and sustain service centers' expenses.
    For example, in India, for the cost of replacing a cracked iPhone 6s screen, you can get an entire phone, a Redmi Note 4 for lesser cash.
    You think we're fools??

      • ?
      • Anonymous
      • Pxn
      • 17 Feb 2017

      A good legislation that needs to brought in everywhere. Safety concerns may be legit, but you issue instructions in a way that batteries don't catch fire while repairing. I would add that just as FCC scrutinizes every phone for their compliance, phones/others should be tested for repair-ability too before being allowed.

        • A
        • Anonym
        • 60J
        • 17 Feb 2017

        Anonym, 17 Feb 2017They aren't. All they need to do is document how to repair ... moreJust to be clear, the objective is to stop replacing whole parts at gauging rates (such as logic-boards) and allow to do actual repairs (fix the component that failed within the logic-board).

        It's mostly an anti-waste, very sane measure.

          • A
          • Anonym
          • 60J
          • 17 Feb 2017

          Anonymous, 16 Feb 2017I don't agree with the bill then. Why should manufacturers... moreThey aren't. All they need to do is document how to repair the phone (schematics mostly), if they want to profit by selling their own parts or other OEMs pitch-in is entirely their decision.

            • D
            • AnonD-308243
            • fjR
            • 16 Feb 2017

            Anonymous, 16 Feb 2017I don't agree with the bill then. Why should manufacturers... moreok think of it like this, you have a motor vehicle that can only be repaired at the dealership and lets say u dont agree with the amount they charge for the service amount they quote and on top of that there is a clause in thier ownership condition that states that should u have the vehicle repaired by anyone else other thwn their dealership branch they will no longer provided further service and void the warranty and halt all services that were due to u. the motor industry is one that has transcendet this kind of practice hance standards like obd2 were implemented to ensure that consumers can have a choice of where thier vehicles are diagnosed and repaired. i belive now that with all the governing bodies developing standards for electronics consumers should have the right to choose who can repair thier devices.

              • ?
              • Anonymous
              • 9AR
              • 16 Feb 2017

              AnonD-308243, 16 Feb 2017the issue is not the physical repairs its about oems allowi... moreI don't agree with the bill then. Why should manufacturers be forced to sell parts to third party repair shops? It should be the manufacturers choice.

              This is just the third parties crying. The average consumer doesn't care. Myself included.

                • ?
                • Anonymous
                • 3uW
                • 16 Feb 2017

                Another reason to hate Apple...

                  • D
                  • AnonD-308243
                  • f4K
                  • 16 Feb 2017

                  Anonymous, 16 Feb 2017Just look on the internet, tutorials galore. Just look on ... morethe issue is not the physical repairs its about oems allowing the customer to go to third party repair shops to have work done on thier phones without voiding the warranty. and the oems are greedy and don't want to allow that coz it means customers dont have to face fixed prices for oem only repairs.

                    • ?
                    • Anonymous
                    • wnx
                    • 16 Feb 2017

                    Just look on the internet, tutorials galore. Just look on ebay, parts galore. Anyone who really wants to fix their iphone themselves already can with resources online.

                      • D
                      • AnonD-645112
                      • 7MX
                      • 16 Feb 2017

                      Apple shouldn't fight the legislation, they should make their phones easier to repair.

                        • c
                        • consumersmartphone
                        • K5u
                        • 16 Feb 2017

                        If this act is to hide something in Apple product and need permission to open it lol My thought, Trump is behind this act lol.

                        BTW they now how to make money right? No one better than apple in way to make money on phone industry. Salute lol

                        I need to tell my sister before she buy iPhone 8 XD Thanks God, you make me skip iPhone at number 7.

                          They just want to keep it a closed eco system and if third party try and fix things well its on your shoulders to put up with it not theirs.

                            • A
                            • Anonymous
                            • wu4
                            • 16 Feb 2017

                            corporate greed...........

                              • A
                              • Anonym
                              • 60J
                              • 16 Feb 2017

                              industry lobbyists have used the argument that "broken glass could cut the fingers of consumers who try to repair their screens"

                              How about the argument that phones with glass can cut the face of those who just use them, therefore they should be banned? Not so funny now, is it dear lobbyists...

                                • A
                                • Anonym
                                • 60J
                                • 16 Feb 2017

                                Except for the very first Apple computer, this is Apple's history -- they see it as fully owning the hardware you buy. Despite being yours, there's very little you can do without reaching-out to Apple.

                                Obviously opening-up just a little this highly profitable closed-system is something Apple will fight to the death (even if it's just for repairing, as in not actually changing anything outside of Apple's specifications/restrictions).

                                  • ?
                                  • Anonymous
                                  • krW
                                  • 15 Feb 2017

                                  A repair person could do the same thing. What's you point?

                                    • ?
                                    • Anonymous
                                    • Iaq
                                    • 15 Feb 2017

                                    I don't normally knock on Apple, but this is just pathetic. It's an obvious attempt at money-grubbing if they can force people to just buy a new phone.

                                      • B
                                      • Big_Apple_Lover
                                      • kww
                                      • 15 Feb 2017

                                      Fans: "All hail, APPLE!"
                                      Apple: "Yes, we love making $. Please become our slaves, our products will empower you to live a "free" and "happy" life with the purpose of buying more of our products forever and ever!"
                                      Fans: *applause*

                                        • K
                                        • Kasutpinjam
                                        • KZ8
                                        • 15 Feb 2017

                                        .alpha, 15 Feb 2017I support Right to Repair bill but at least iPhone is repai... moreAt least, I had something to laugh at today. Thanks