Sunday Debate: iPhone XS Max vs a used car

23 September 2018
Apple's latest flagship costs as much as a used car - does it make sense to spend as much on a phone?

Sort by:

  • i
  • imRGZ
  • upg
  • 24 Sep 2018

vrvly, 24 Sep 2018In this age most of cost are not for hw, though some brands... moreWhat new tech Apple brought with 2018 iPhones exactly to be priced exorbitantly? Are there any ground breaking features? Is there any change from last year's iPhones to demand such a big price jump?

    • i
    • imRGZ
    • upg
    • 24 Sep 2018

    Duel, 24 Sep 2018but can your DSLR make calls? or check email or surf web? It does take pics which are at least 1000 times better than your iPhone. And for the things you mentioned, any smartphone in the world is enough. Why one should shell out 1000$ plus for the tasks you mentioned? Until unless one doesnt care about money and has tons at home to throw away.

      • A
      • Alex
      • Ss1
      • 24 Sep 2018

      You have to be MAD to pay 1650 Euros for a phone that does... NOTHING ELSE than iPhone 6 and looks the same. And 6 months later they come up with an other SCAM phone so after you pay a fortune you have an old model.

        • i
        • imRGZ
        • upg
        • 24 Sep 2018

        Anonymous, 24 Sep 2018Meanwhile people are ignoring that Samsung also selling the... moreYes, Note9 is also costly but it doesn't reach 1500USD level of iPhone XS Max. Even then when compared feature to feature, Note9 beats iPhone hands down. You will get more bang for same 1000. In my country for example, cheapest iPhone XR costs 10k more! Which even doesn't have 1080p LCD display! And base version(64gb) of XS costs 32k more than it, XS Max 42k more. I can buy a note9 and OnePlus 6/6T for the price of a single XS. That's two flagships of respective brands. And if you take 512gb version of XS Max, then you can buy two Note9's or four OnePlus 6/6T's and a fitbit for the same price. Now do you really consider Note9 is costly when compared with 2018 iPhones?

          • D
          • Duel
          • Scq
          • 24 Sep 2018

          OneDaftDuck, 24 Sep 2018The iPhone is now price competitive with a DLSR or Mirror-l... morebut can your DSLR make calls? or check email or surf web?

            • ?
            • Anonymous
            • F9r
            • 24 Sep 2018

            You could buy a car at the absolute bottom of its curve and it will only make money in the future. Spend £1000 on a phone and its worth £50 in 10 years, spend a grand on something quirky and fun and it will only go up in value in the end.

            And why bother arguing about using taxis and the like, its still adding pollution and its not exactly like making a phone is emission neutral!! Thats the problem with people today, they HAVE to have the latest and greatest and stuff sits in landfill where it could have been used for many years afterwards.

              In this age most of cost are not for hw, though some brands squeeze money for memory or just being unique. There are people that can afford that and its true that quality and services are mostly worth money, even more if you also count the selling price of an year old phone. New trends and cool tech comes however from earning money so be it for selling hw or services or brand high, and investing in ideas, r&d. Apple should be the best in that area.

                Anonymous, 24 Sep 2018But don't you own an iPhone X?I do, but it's not technically mine, It's my work phone, the moment I will leave the work (And I love my work) the iPhone will return.
                Despite such a closed OS, it's MUCH easier to Develop apps for Apple than for android.
                But all in all I'll go full power Android if I could ;D

                  Duel, 24 Sep 2018Then why are you obsessed with Apple then?Because I develop apps for them. And I know their OS from every f***ing direction possible. I am obsessed with apple because my husband gave me an iPod touch, and I really liked it, but it broke, not to mention their OS is horrible, and I want apple to think open source.

                    • ?
                    • Anonymous
                    • bJA
                    • 24 Sep 2018

                    Meanwhile people are ignoring that Samsung also selling their Note 9 at $1k. How many Big Mac I can get for $1k?

                    I don't get it. People go nuts about Apple prices, yet are okay with Samsung's ridiculous and as expensive prices. Stupid fanboys.

                      • ?
                      • Anonymous
                      • wry
                      • 24 Sep 2018

                      Realistic1, 24 Sep 2018Old cars are OK, but a car under 2000 Euros would be defini... moreMaybe learn how to drive properly in the first place and don't crash.

                        • F
                        • FaceGle
                        • Q5x
                        • 24 Sep 2018

                        Yordan, I agree that the MINI Cooper is ugly!
                        But, but, but, because of £1449 (iPhone XS Max) ,I bought a BRAND NEW YAMAHA SNIPER 150, the 2018 Edition. If you know what I mean.
                        I can go to any place where I want by riding on it (of course).
                        Can you ride your iPhone XS Max and go to the place that you want?. of course not.

                          ****
                          Many people buy a phone of 1200 euros just to send whatsapp, check the mail, and upload photos to facebook and instagram and resolve discussions reading the wikipedia ...
                          I'm wrong or not ?.
                          It's the reality, but since they want the latter, they buy the latest iPhone model to say: "Look how cool I am that I have the iPhone XS...
                          ****

                            • O
                            • OneDaftDuck
                            • aHV
                            • 24 Sep 2018

                            Duel, 24 Sep 2018"If somebody cares about photography that much, they would ... moreThe iPhone is now price competitive with a DLSR or Mirror-less camera now. Although, the quality will be way better, more zoom, ect. It is bonkers that a phone is priced as much.

                              • W
                              • Why?
                              • PF9
                              • 24 Sep 2018

                              Why I need a mini when i have a ferrari?
                              I only texting and calling why i need an lastest iphone?

                                Hellboy., 24 Sep 2018Yordan: "And the car is ugly." Ugly is the iPhone price,... moreSpot on,mate

                                  • O
                                  • OneDaftDuck
                                  • aHV
                                  • 24 Sep 2018

                                  Make all the arguments you want the Mini Cooper even as old as it is will probably last longer than the iPhone. It is kind of funny that the 256GB iPhone is now competitive with the 256GB MacBook. I think people should absolutely start to think about what that money means, you are getting so much less with that silly phone. That is why I like this article.

                                    Yordan: "And the car is ugly."

                                    Ugly is the iPhone price, a Mini Cooper is a good looking car.

                                      • D
                                      • Duel
                                      • Scq
                                      • 24 Sep 2018

                                      starison, 24 Sep 2018If somebody cares about photography that much, they would c... more"If somebody cares about photography that much, they would carry a DSLR or a mirrorless camera with them. "

                                      Not this stuff again! No need to go over the top. That's like saying if you want to produce music you need very expensive studio, even when you can make great quality music in your home studio. Just like you can take great pics with today's best cams.

                                      Carrying extra camera isn't fun, best cam is what you have when you see something interesting, your DSLR at home doesn't help you much to capture that moment.

                                        • D
                                        • AnonD-731363
                                        • SH3
                                        • 24 Sep 2018

                                        Xiaomi, 24 Sep 2018You are right, Tim Cook does not have any idea how to run a... moreMan yes but since Jobs is gone apple started many wars with other competitors, apple removed jack, apple removed thing you could use to attach and connect your earphones, apple used notch and all copy. Apple still even in end of 2018 cant use support quickcharge, dash charge, SVOOC, Apple still dont support dual separate sim sots, apple still dont support memory card and there is a lot more which they dont but any other company do.
                                        Apple way.