Apple is violating a Motorola patent, judge confirms

25 April, 2012
The decision isn't final yet - it needs to be reviewed by a commission before it can be enforced.

Sort by:

  • ?
  • Anonymous
  • v6u
  • 26 Apr 2012

yessssssssssss!

    • A
    • Android Fans
    • TSM
    • 26 Apr 2012

    Look like every competitor try crack Google.

      • ?
      • Anonymous
      • 5B7
      • 26 Apr 2012

      claiming that Moto is using some patents, which are essential to the industry, which they are not supposed to do ????
      WTF IS APPLE DOIN THEN

        • ?
        • Anonymous
        • 4bv
        • 25 Apr 2012

        gooooo Motorola smash the fruity to the ground.

          • D
          • AnonD-52133
          • 3Ts
          • 25 Apr 2012

          But in case not in this, motorola linux phone - RAZR2 V8 with modded firmware has the speciality like in iphone called SIRI... but in motorola this was just voice commands, but, it was really the same, long press up arrow and than say words etc, what time is it, read last mssage, call to, etc it was the same, but apple only make it in ways with using internet... so for me. Motorola is the best. Thank you. I am Mr Martin Siry

            • ?
            • Anonymous
            • mxS
            • 25 Apr 2012

            Anonymous, 25 Apr 2012WhyBecause Apple come on the scene years after everyone else and try and claim others ideas as their own. They are getting exactly what they deserve and not before time.

              • L
              • Luna Schlockier
              • HIc
              • 25 Apr 2012

              Motorola is now doing the right thing...

                • ?
                • Anonymous
                • nxH
                • 25 Apr 2012

                AnonD-12163, 25 Apr 2012Apple deserves this.Why

                  • k
                  • kiloh3rtz
                  • ms0
                  • 25 Apr 2012

                  Here we go now that google android father own moto mobile division they start hitting hard and low apple soon other none-moto phones will fallow quess why android lose market shareres and they wanna get some action...
                  P.S:Android lovers start buying moto phones os android will come optimized soon for moto

                    • D
                    • AnonD-12163
                    • EcV
                    • 25 Apr 2012

                    Apple deserves this.

                      • A
                      • Apple_nitpicks_more
                      • DWC
                      • 25 Apr 2012

                      louigi, 25 Apr 2012These guys are seriously arguing about a tiny little techni... moreAnd yet Apple nitpicks even more over non-technical details such as design. Technical details are what makes things work. "Design" is just aesthetics.

                        • P
                        • Pwltho
                        • vV5
                        • 25 Apr 2012

                        Well, it reminds me of the billy Joel song "we didn't start the fire"......but sadly, Apple did it...LOL

                          • N
                          • Nav
                          • JCk
                          • 25 Apr 2012

                          I think this is fair. think u r a researcher and spend millions of dollar on a research and a company copys ur research when u r done. why did u waited ur time and money why don't u just copy. think.....

                            • D
                            • AnonD-52113
                            • RdX
                            • 25 Apr 2012

                            gean_paulo19, 25 Apr 2012I know that Apple won't do that! They have their own origin... moreSeriously...apple has originality when it came out with the ipod, or Macintosh computer (a life changing invention). But in the mobile phone market lets compare. Motorola first phone was in Sept. 1983. Iphone first came out in 2007. C'mon lets not talk originality against Motorola when it comes to mobile phones "the father of mobile phones"

                              • D
                              • AnonD-52113
                              • RdX
                              • 25 Apr 2012

                              louigi, 25 Apr 2012These guys are seriously arguing about a tiny little techni... moreI don't normally post comments on here, but I just couldn't sit through this one. Have you not been reading the news about these lame patent lawsuits? Petty is right...but its apple own petty and selfishness!! Instead of blocking technology how about just focusing on making good phones. (don't give me crap about being an android fanboy either, i'd buy an apple its just i'm not brainwashed as easily....good products, bad company) Enough said.

                                • ?
                                • Anonymous
                                • SvB
                                • 25 Apr 2012

                                Wow! Good job motorola! i hope you will win this! I am a big fan of you since my first phone :D! MOTOROLA RULEZ!

                                  • ?
                                  • Anonymous
                                  • p%n
                                  • 25 Apr 2012

                                  louigi, 25 Apr 2012These guys are seriously arguing about a tiny little techni... moreExcuse me but who started all these antics?? Apple. So they are getting exactly what they deserve. If you stir up a hornets nest don't complain when you get stung.

                                    • B
                                    • Barfman
                                    • Ycv
                                    • 25 Apr 2012

                                    louigi, 25 Apr 2012These guys are seriously arguing about a tiny little techni... moreAre you serious? After all the lawsuits Apple have started, you're going to say that Moto is pathetic? Apple is guilty of starting this whole problem, you should be pissed at them. I hope they all just eventually call a stalemate, but Apple is far more guilty than the rest for endless lawsuits.

                                      • l
                                      • louigi
                                      • nU$
                                      • 25 Apr 2012

                                      These guys are seriously arguing about a tiny little technical thing which reduces 3g call noise, come on, these are meant to be multi-million/billion pound companies and they're acting like toddlers fighting over toys in a sand pit. I hope Apple win this, Motorola are just being pathetic!

                                        • D
                                        • DAN13L
                                        • kxI
                                        • 25 Apr 2012

                                        Anonymous, 25 Apr 2012yeah and thats why they sold it to google, very richYeah, Sucks that they suck at Marketing. i have been giving Motorola my money for over 15 years. They will always be #1 to me