Judge throws out Samsung's claim of jury misconduct

18 December, 2012
Meanwhile, Apple's motion to get permanent injunction on Samsung's infringing products is denied.

Sort by:

  • D
  • AnonD-56946
  • Xu9
  • 18 Dec 2012

Instead of banning samsung products in usa if apple were able to ban Samsung Galaxy Ace in India 1.5 years before, then it will become huge loss for samsung because Galaxy Ace sold like hot cakes in India & it looks same as iPhone in respects to Shape, Size, etc.

    • t
    • the_seba
    • 3QY
    • 18 Dec 2012

    Isn't every US jury biased towards Apple? Every member of the jury owns a MacBook, an iPad and an iPhone... and maybe a Samsung fridge. How is that not biased already??

      • j
      • jaja2756
      • D9t
      • 18 Dec 2012

      Apple haven't won anything yet until iphone7s.

        • l
        • lol
        • IVN
        • 18 Dec 2012

        Anonymous, 18 Dec 2012Your comment "S3 and Note 2 no longer look like any ap... moreYour statement might be true if apple didnt sue sgIII and note II right now .
        However , its proven wrong .

          • ?
          • Anonymous
          • IV{
          • 18 Dec 2012

          Anonymous, 18 Dec 2012yet Apple wants the S3 and Note II banned as well, so your ... moreApologies, not your admission, but the original comment that I replied to.

            • ?
            • Anonymous
            • IV{
            • 18 Dec 2012

            Anonymous, 18 Dec 2012yet Apple wants the S3 and Note II banned as well, so your ... moreOnly when relating to the S3 and Note 2, but not with the original models, my point remains. Also, was talking about your admission, not Samsung's.

            Truth is, its an open secret that Samsung copycatted their way to the top, even before copying Apple. It just gets technical in the courts. Samsung have certainly learnt a painful lesson, and now at least they know the consequences.

              • D
              • AnonD-88512
              • 0ph
              • 18 Dec 2012

              Ever since this war began I've hated both Apple and Samsung for wasting their creative energy on dirty corporate politics.

              Nokia and RIM may not be market leaders anymore, but at least they're using their time to better innovation instead of fighting it out..

                • ?
                • Anonymous
                • 9xd
                • 18 Dec 2012

                You should read this way:
                Apple lost the injunction case, no more ammo,
                and Samsung can proceed to an appeal court for a professional judgement,
                and Judge Koh really don't want this case.

                  • ?
                  • Anonymous
                  • q{p
                  • 18 Dec 2012

                  Anonymous, 18 Dec 2012Your comment "S3 and Note 2 no longer look like any ap... moreyet Apple wants the S3 and Note II banned as well, so your point is moot.

                    • o
                    • oppokun
                    • 9Lb
                    • 18 Dec 2012

                    Anonymous, 18 Dec 2012Apple has used up all their ammo.. S3 and Note 2 no longer ... moreGoogle going down? You're kidding right?

                      • ?
                      • Anonymous
                      • IV{
                      • 18 Dec 2012

                      AnonD-77544, 18 Dec 2012Who says samsung cant win a case against apple in US.......... moreIf you read back in history, Apple were shocked when they were fined 100million after Creative sued them using patents. After this, Apple rightfully patented their products to defend themselves against future lawsuits. So maybe you want to give Creative a bit of blame in this regard.

                      http://www.cultofmac.com/194822/steve-jobs-vowed-to-patent-everything-apple-invented-after-being-stung-by-100m-ipod-fine-report/

                        • ?
                        • Anonymous
                        • IV{
                        • 18 Dec 2012

                        Anonymous, 18 Dec 2012Apple has used up all their ammo.. S3 and Note 2 no longer ... moreYour comment "S3 and Note 2 no longer look like any apple products... " is ironic because:

                        1. It is an admission that Apple is right in the case that the previous products DID look like Apple products
                        2. S3 and Note 2 no longer looking like Apple products is what Apple wanted all along. They don't care if it is better or not, just stop copying.

                          • ?
                          • Anonymous
                          • HIb
                          • 18 Dec 2012

                          Crapple failed!!!
                          hahaha

                            • k
                            • kirk
                            • 9xB
                            • 18 Dec 2012

                            there will be war here soon. i am waiting, pls don't disappoint us.

                              • j
                              • johnmac
                              • X3t
                              • 18 Dec 2012

                              grayfox1574, 18 Dec 2012Winning a case in the US against one of the biggest compani... moreYes ,if only these jurors realized their protecting a company so patriotic they make everything off shore.

                                • D
                                • AnonD-77544
                                • sSK
                                • 18 Dec 2012

                                grayfox1574, 18 Dec 2012Winning a case in the US against one of the biggest compani... moreWho says samsung cant win a case against apple in US....... samsung is not like apple who infringes everyone whom they feel is a threat to their market sales.......... n tell me who started this f****g patent war n court cases.......... the ans is 'Shameless Apple'

                                  • ?
                                  • Anonymous
                                  • uRE
                                  • 18 Dec 2012

                                  Apple has used up all their ammo.. S3 and Note 2 no longer look like any apple products... and is having more features and better battery life then iphone.

                                  With iphone 5 .. apple is starting to loose grip compared to android. No wonder steve wants google down...

                                    • D
                                    • AnonD-86517
                                    • U{M
                                    • 18 Dec 2012

                                    AnonD-81714, 18 Dec 2012Go go go AndroidAndroid has nothing to do with it..

                                      • D
                                      • AnonD-81714
                                      • 3sr
                                      • 18 Dec 2012

                                      Go go go Android

                                        • g
                                        • grayfox1574
                                        • 3R6
                                        • 18 Dec 2012

                                        Winning a case in the US against one of the biggest companies in the US, who do you think would win?!