WhatsApp head criticizes Telegram for misleading its users over its encryption

14 February 2023
Will Cathcart, the head of WhatsApp at Meta, claims that government agencies have access to secret chats in Telegram.

Sort by:

  • k
  • kato
  • ke}
  • 06 Mar 2023

None of these free apps are secure. A paid fully E2EE app that doesn’t request location permissions at all, uses verified encryption (no custom algorithms) and comes with enhanced security features like panic wipe, stealth mode (hides app), duress password, with an option to have the app on a secure device is best. Free apps mean they sell your data, and are spying on you and your device. My associates and myself use SecureCrypt. Been using since 2019. Best encrypted app I have ever used and I have used all of them. Flawless.

    • j
    • javk
    • Sv2
    • 21 Feb 2023

    I think most secure Messaging App is Messenger from Utopia P2P ecosystem. I use this messenger to remain anonymous. More better than Whatsapp or Telegram

      • Y
      • Yeah
      • p2L
      • 18 Feb 2023

      I don't believe any of them. I don't even depend on any of them. You never know they will pull the plug. I also don't care if Zuckerberg is reading my messages. Before talking about encryption and stuff they better fix the bugs in them. Like, I am deleting a message on my desktop app and it is still on the phone. I can open Telegram on multiple devices using their app but I have to open WhatsApp only on one phone and multiple browsers. Who cares? Also telegram needs to fix the messages not going to the receiver. I tried it on multiple phones and a PC. I send message from one number to another. It waits for long time until it is received.
      They only needs fixing. I don't care about improvements. Keep them as they are. Just don't make them worse. That's enough... Maybe they should release old versions.
      And it's not only them. Everybody updating anything is just making things worse. Look at Win 11. Where is the improvement? It is worse than Win 10. What is show more options after right click anyway? Who thought of it? And with iPhone software updates, battery lasts less after any update. Where is the number row on the keyboard anyway?
      I have a laptop. I install Win 10 or Win 11 on it. It connects to Wi-Fi but no internet. Then I install Win7. It connects to Wi-Fi and there is internet. Which means what? Is technology getting worse or what?

        Anonymous, 15 Feb 2023Such unnecessary comment, if you have read the article. ... morenormal (not secret) chats are encrypted.
        but server of telegram has the encryption key as well.
        if you want high level of features, like what telegram offers, there is no choice! you can't have this features with e2ee.

          • ?
          • Anonymous
          • 70d
          • 16 Feb 2023

          Anonymous, 15 Feb 2023Anyone who believes any of these messaging apps be it Teleg... moreStart reading.

            • C
            • Carol
            • mek
            • 15 Feb 2023

            And to come to the conclusion, Telegram is actually real end-to-end encryption when Secret chats, and server-client encryption when normal using, while way more private and secure then whatsapp.
            Yet, this abomination of privacy eater by the name of facebook that tried to delete it's reputation through "meta" that did nothing but wrong in it's past and very near past, dare to accuse Telegram of misleading, and liying? This is darn right sp!tfull. The only thing i wish to that Peachtunel of a Zucker, is to sell his life to google and receive a bigfoot in his can for it. All "pun's" intend.

              • C
              • Carol
              • mek
              • 15 Feb 2023

              0odle-noodle, 15 Feb 2023Ofcourse, that is correct. Everyone spies on you to a certa... moreOf course, even hedgehogs, pigeons and lizards spy on you. That's why they're everywhere where people are. Last time i saw an Owl, it was wearing a spyglass too.

                • C
                • Carol
                • mek
                • 15 Feb 2023

                Anonymous, 15 Feb 2023This is the truth. No wonder majority of people are using w... moreYour understanding of what encyption means equals 0 and a lot of zeros after...yet you talk about it like you're the main Computer scientist of nato with skils in security and encryption.
                If people like you would do less talking and more learning, there would be a way better world out there. It is easyer tough to talk without knowing instead of learning before talking.

                  • C
                  • Carol
                  • mek
                  • 15 Feb 2023

                  Anonymous, 15 Feb 2023Anyone who believes any of these messaging apps be it Teleg... moreYou believing that their is nothing like that, pretty much makes you an ignorant about tech, how it works and how to protetct your privacy. Only because you do not know or understand technology, does not mean that you know something that others do not. You just talked not to shut up.

                    • A
                    • Arol
                    • mek
                    • 15 Feb 2023

                    AnonD-1037771, 15 Feb 2023No thanks! I'd rather use flying pigeons or simply sho... moreWhat a... you just started a war because you hate the people of a country, yet you talk about love?

                      Anonymous, 15 Feb 2023So, you just admitted that Telegram doesnt have spy level/e... moreNo, I trust WhatsApp even less + it's missing the elementary features that telegram offers.

                        user, 14 Feb 2023I'm not a Meta fan, but to say anything is really diff... moreOfcourse, that is correct. Everyone spies on you to a certain extent, no matter who they are and how much they say they don't, but they definitely do. What I'm saying is that (besides amazon) meta most definitely collects the most data out of any tech company in existence.

                          • S
                          • SmartBXy
                          • KRW
                          • 15 Feb 2023

                          Nah I don't care what ever meta say at least my telegram data will not lose if I forgot to backup

                            • ?
                            • Anonymous
                            • XS%
                            • 15 Feb 2023

                            AnonD-1037771, 15 Feb 2023No thanks! I'd rather use flying pigeons or simply sho... moreDurov isn't Russian, at least not anymore.

                              • D
                              • AnonD-1037771
                              • 3RM
                              • 15 Feb 2023

                              alirezaasol, 14 Feb 2023Telegram is the best messaging app. just try it. best spee... moreNo thanks! I'd rather use flying pigeons or simply shout my lungs out than use rusian software! Boycott everything from there!
                              Make LOVE not war! 🖖👽💖✌️

                                Anonymous, 15 Feb 2023Anyone who believes any of these messaging apps be it Teleg... moreBest comment

                                  • ?
                                  • Anonymous
                                  • 7kn
                                  • 15 Feb 2023

                                  Anyone who believes any of these messaging apps be it Telegram or whatsapp is private is a brainwashed moron.

                                    • ?
                                    • Anonymous
                                    • Kir
                                    • 15 Feb 2023

                                    Mr. Anonymous, 14 Feb 2023I don't need spy level privacy for my conversations, b... moreSo, you just admitted that Telegram doesnt have spy level/encrypted privacy, and not as secure as Whatsapp right?

                                    Because thats exactly the main point of this article.

                                      • A
                                      • Arol
                                      • mek
                                      • 15 Feb 2023

                                      Anonymous, 15 Feb 2023Such unnecessary comment, if you have read the article. ... moreActually it is Server-client encrypted when in default, and end-to-end encrypted when in secret chat.
                                      The problem with real end-to-end encryotion in Telegram is that a user loses pretty much every function like edit sended messages or delete them for the receiver and other stuff. Butwell,when somebody wants to use secret chat, he is actually talkimg end-to-end. What funny is,is that facebook, comments about security of their whatsapp as if it would be secure and private, if that would be the case, nobody would ever be able to restore backups, or delete for others, orother functions whatsapp copied from telegram. Anyway how would those all be possible in an end-to-end encryption?
                                      Well, what is clear is, that none of them is to be trusted.

                                        • ?
                                        • Anonymous
                                        • Kir
                                        • 15 Feb 2023

                                        Anonymous, 14 Feb 2023Telegram is spreading fake news. Any whatsapps user cou... moreThis is the truth. No wonder majority of people are using whatsapp, as the most secure messenger apps with encrypted message, encrypted group chats, and encrypted calls.

                                        Many other apps may have gimmick features, but still in daily conversation, majority of people uses whatsapp.

                                        This is the truth, that must be accepted by any iMessage/Telegram/Line user.

                                        👍