Consumer Reports: iPhone screen no match for Android flagships

17 October, 2013
The latest Consumer Reports review praises the iPhone's new tech, but says it's behind in several key areas.

Sort by:

  • D
  • AnonD-187611
  • xZs
  • 17 Oct 2013

No match in what aspects? the bump in pixel density its barely notable, and the Iphone screen its consistenly more bright and colors are more accurate while having enough punch than others AMOLED or overly saturated artificial LCD screens (I'm pointing at you S4 and G2 respectively), so the only thing they are really better its at being big... and consumers have not punished apple for that, they still sale more 5s that they can produce. This article use a series of assumptions that only contribute to make the believe that its an Apple hate site and its noticeable kind to Samsung.

I don't think that a company that its not competitive would have displace Cocacola and many others as the most valuable brand on earth, and I don't think a phone that is not well received by consumer or that consumer consider slacking would be the best sold smart phone on earth. Other manufactures have push on cosumer bigger than life screen that most consumer didn't really ask for, if you ask S4 users what's the ony thing they don't like about their device in most of the cases they will say "it's too big" and what makes it big... the monstrous screen.

It is tech site like this one and other android fan base site that are trying to push apple to use a bigger screen, not consumers, Apple will surely will start putting bigger screens on their phones the minute they start to loose sales due to this, however since they target audience still favors quality over quantity, they stick to 4" screens.

    • t
    • tabularasa
    • M4q
    • 17 Oct 2013

    Iphone 5(s) compared to other devices is tooo ugly...

    to much space above and under the screen,,,, apple, maybe you revolutionized the smartphone scene but today your phones are ugly, small screen, big bazels, low quality screen, no USB conector... the prize is so high the device is so down down down.....

    take htc or sony.... you can't compare htc one or z1 to the iPhone....
    samsung s4 build from plastic has a better look than the iphone5....

    so sad...

      • D
      • AnonD-27650
      • LaV
      • 17 Oct 2013

      AnonD-10287, 17 Oct 2013you must be joking, right? you know that after 6 months si... morei am using an htc one and one mini after changing from iphone 5...the screens are good which i said but for me and my own tastes the iphone 5 screen just gives you more realistic colors or to my eyes it does...it is all about our own personal like and dislike...as long as i dont see any pixels i am happy, im a busy guy i dont have time to watch movies on my phone, that is what my tv is for ... i would have kept my htc one s or xperia s if the ppi was better to be honest

        • i
        • iron_buzz
        • uCd
        • 17 Oct 2013

        5" too big in my pocket and i must carry by hand that not effective and mobilize when you must move fast!!!
        note 3 ??? hello.., are you king kong community lol too bigger and can't fits in the pocket
        big screen only for women because they move slow like a snail

          • g
          • gam30toronto
          • RXg
          • 17 Oct 2013

          chester, 17 Oct 2013Sony Xperia Z1f or mini is the answer many are waiting for.... moreSorry this Sony is no where near as elegant as the iphone. It looks like every other android out there. So please don't think this is THE ANSWER.

            • ?
            • Anonymous
            • nyF
            • 17 Oct 2013

            gam30toronto, 17 Oct 2013thank god there are some apple supporters here. I always ha... moreWait a minute, you actually think there's a god helping out Apple people?

              • g
              • gam30toronto
              • RXg
              • 17 Oct 2013

              D Man, 17 Oct 2013Oh common you iPhone fans, u guys know that apple will stil... morewe don't know what the future holds for the iPhone. The fact is that Apple is the only company that can fit everything in a 4 inch screen and still sells millions in 2013. That is something we cannot deny. Can Samsung make a 4' flagship and sell as much as the iphone 5S? In Contrast, can Apple make a 4'7 flagship and sell as much as Samsung? You think about it.

                • D
                • AnonD-27650
                • LaV
                • 17 Oct 2013

                Anonymous, 17 Oct 2013You don't know what you are saying, do you know that Note 3... morehmmmm . here we are talking about screens and you are bringing up browser, games battery etc...why is that i wonder? i am not in any way some fan boy of any phone but it seems i have hurt your feelings about your beloved android device seeing as you have diverted from the subject so much...and please explain how someones personal opinion can be a lie??? i think its about time you put your phone down and got yourself a wee bit of a life ... it is after all a phone

                  • I
                  • Ixil
                  • m}9
                  • 17 Oct 2013

                  Really, 17 Oct 2013What an apple hate article. "If apple want to rema... moreYou know, you said it better than anyone... "Just because the geeks love a mini laptop doesn't mean the cool people with money and girls have to like it. And that's life."...

                  People who want to use their phones go for bigger screens, people who buy phones for status, getting girls or otherwise not knowing what to do with their money go for iPhones... It doesn't make it better...

                    Joey, 17 Oct 2013What would be good if Apple or the major Android manufactur... moreSony Xperia Z1f or mini is the answer many are waiting for.

                    Sony Xperia Z1f or mini specs
                    -dimensions 127 x 64.9 x 9.4 mm (5.0 x 2.56 x 0.37 in)
                    -Weight 140g
                    -2g,3g and 4G+ network capability for all networks
                    -4.3inch 720p 341ppi display
                    -It has a Qualcomm Snapdragon 800 processor clocked at 2.2GHz, 2GB of RAM, and 16GB of storage plus upto 64GB microSD card slot.
                    -OS Android 4.2.2
                    -20.7MP EXMOR back camera sensor with 1080p@30fps
                    -2MP front camera sensor with 1080p@30fps
                    -2,300mAh battery
                    -dust and water resistant IP 58 certified

                    Unfortunately it will be available in December 2013 in Japan only.Sony is committing suicide by not releasing it worldwide.

                      • g
                      • gam30toronto
                      • RXg
                      • 17 Oct 2013

                      Really, 17 Oct 2013What an apple hate article. "If apple want to rema... morethank god there are some apple supporters here. I always had to fight alone in those samsung news sections. lolz

                        • D
                        • D Man
                        • N9@
                        • 17 Oct 2013

                        Oh common you iPhone fans, u guys know that apple will still increase the size of the iPhone eventually thus making your comments now pointless.
                        There is no how you can compare a 4.5" screen to a 4" one in many aspects. Things like browsing, gaming and watching videos all look good on a bigger screen. Even stuffs like reading messages and typing are better. A bigger screen also means more contents are going to fit the screen and reduces scrolling.
                        Apple really needs to up their game as the price they are asking for isnt worth the contents.

                          • ?
                          • Anonymous
                          • v0q
                          • 17 Oct 2013

                          LG is the best Display maker...
                          Iphone 5s display was made by LG

                            • R
                            • Really
                            • 2CF
                            • 17 Oct 2013

                            What an apple hate article.

                            "If apple want to remain competitive"

                            What a ridiculous comment. They sold 9 million phones in 2 days with their "terrible" screen because it does what people want. Just because the geeks love a mini laptop doesn't mean the cool people with money and girls have to like it. And that's life.

                              • D
                              • AnonD-977
                              • v}7
                              • 17 Oct 2013

                              Anonymous, 17 Oct 2013apple keeps selling you polished turds.. and yep u guys kee... moreTalking about polished turds:-

                              S4
                              S4 Octo
                              S4 Active
                              S4 Mini
                              S4 cat 4

                              How many more ways to polish the same turd?

                                • D
                                • AnonD-977
                                • v}7
                                • 17 Oct 2013

                                Chew, 17 Oct 2013Seriously you dont need a Galaxy Note 3'isk screen. Thats p... moreBig screen?

                                That's why I've got a retina iPad.

                                  • D
                                  • AnonD-194677
                                  • M4x
                                  • 17 Oct 2013

                                  When it comes to touch responsiveness is the other way around.The top android flagships can't even beat the obsolete iphone 4

                                    • D
                                    • AnonD-977
                                    • v}7
                                    • 17 Oct 2013

                                    Anonymous, 17 Oct 2013Actually i have a lot of problems with my iPod Touch 5th ge... moreAgawi TouchMark.

                                    Independent testing says you are wrong.

                                      AnonD-977, 17 Oct 2013Influential? Nine million sales in three days. About ... moreRead this: http://blog.gsmarena.com/samsung-galaxy-s4-screen-got-a-ul-certification-for-display-image-quality-thanks-to-its-accurate-adobe-rgb-support/

                                      Do we cares if it use some kind of Pentile matrix?

                                      Nope.

                                        • D
                                        • AnonD-190025
                                        • Kxb
                                        • 17 Oct 2013

                                        I have been using nexus since 3 months and i can say it's nowhere as good as my iphone 5 which it replaced under direct sunlight.
                                        The big screen is welcome though but when it comes to direct sunlight most other phones suck including the s4 and note series.