Nokia N8 vs. Samsung Pixon12 vs. Sony HX5v shootout: Blind test
- u
- unbiased mobile addi
- A5w
- 05 Oct 2010
Anonymous, 05 Oct 2010why is there no comparison of SE Satio maybe they don't have a sony ericson satio
got curious if there is a satio, not sure if it will came close to the result here
hey GSM arena, will you give update with satio?
- F
- Fanboykiller!!
- LdW
- 05 Oct 2010
Firstly, as a lot of others have stated, this blind test was a great idea, props to you gsmarena!
I would have to say that C seems to be the best camera here, judging by the ammout of detail and color rendering in the photos. A would have to be the second best one followed by B.
With that said I think (atleast hope) that;
C = Sony HX5v
A = Nokia N8
B = Samsung Pixon
And to ignorant people stating that Nokia N8 has a bigger sensor then Altek Leo and thus should have a better camera, do your homework! The N8 boosts a CMOS sensor whilst the Altek Leo supposedly will have a CCD sensor. Nevertheless I guess we will have to wait and see until seeing the Altek Leo in action before making a judgement here. In any case, the N8 seems to be a great phone!
- ?
- Anonymous
- 0Fi
- 05 Oct 2010
why is there no comparison of SE Satio
- f
- funkyto
- 3s4
- 05 Oct 2010
unbiased mobile addi, 05 Oct 2010very obvious 1.C-probably sony 2.A-probably N8 3,B-pixon... morei think exactly the same.
- ?
- Anonymous
- pWJ
- 05 Oct 2010
C is clearly best =Sony
great idea to do blind test!
- M
- Mini Me
- 0Um
- 05 Oct 2010
1.C
2.A
3.B
But the differences are so insignificant , this is a job for a professional to tell which is the best. C looks the best in the majority of pictures in my opinion, but A is very good as well , then B is right after them. Like i said, the 3 are almost the same, i don`t think you can tell the difference if you don`t have them side by side. And this already says a lot for the Nokia N8. Competing with the Sony HX5v and being so close( no matter which of the A, B C is the N8) is a big + for the N9 already.
- ?
- Anonymous
- p60
- 05 Oct 2010
C=SONY (1.)
A=N8 (2.)
B=PIXON (3.)
- u
- unbiased mobile addi
- A5w
- 05 Oct 2010
very obvious
1.C-probably sony
2.A-probably N8
3,B-pixon for sure, i own one :)
still N8 can't beat an expensive digicam but still came close
lets see tom who's who but for i am almost 100% sure of my answer
- ?
- Anonymous
- p60
- 05 Oct 2010
C 1.
A 2.
B 3.
I hope that, B is not N8.
- A
- AT
- NC9
- 05 Oct 2010
1. C
2. A
3. B
4. A
5. C
6. C
- M
- Mathew
- 2SR
- 05 Oct 2010
C A B
- d
- dan fason
- muw
- 05 Oct 2010
3- hx5v
2- pixon
1-n8
- A
- AT
- NC9
- 05 Oct 2010
A = Sony X5
B = Samsung pixon
C = Nokia N8
- A
- Addy
- uWS
- 05 Oct 2010
I wish Nokia is on the top of sony and samsung.
C should b Nokia N8
- M
- Morgred
- iDm
- 05 Oct 2010
B>A>C
- f
- follower
- ntg
- 05 Oct 2010
I would have to go with
1-C
2-A
3-B
- ?
- Anonymous
- 0x9
- 05 Oct 2010
C is clearly the best
- S
- Skywalker83
- TsE
- 05 Oct 2010
First of all, great idea!
Here is my order:
1.C,B,A
2.B,A,C
3.A&B,C
4.A,B,C
5.C,B,A
6.C,A,B
7.A,C,B
8.C,A,B
So all three devices have strenghts and weaknesses.
My guess:
A: Pixon
B: Sony
C: Nokia
- N
- Nikoniac
- Sis
- 05 Oct 2010
1.C: good ISO performance
2.A: excellent DOF,too much noise reduction & auto contrast
3:B: piece of crap
- f
- feucht
- jWx
- 05 Oct 2010
seems like a good sign for the N8 that they are all *so* close
there b is on the bottom. I personally think A>C because of the detail and close up text clearness.