Nokia N8 gets lots of stick in early reviews, we wonder why

03 October, 2010
The Nokia N8 started shipping this week and reviews of the Finnish company's latest flagship are spreading like wildfire. Checking out the first batch of those we noticed a certain trend, which we cannot...

Sort by:

  • ?
  • Anonymous
  • t7X
  • 05 Oct 2010

miscof, 05 Oct 2010Sure it might be able to run Symbian OS fine but what happe... moreWhy put android on this? If people want android, they'll buy android phones.


Android is battery eater.

    • m
    • miscof
    • vaQ
    • 05 Oct 2010

    Anonymous, 04 Oct 2010The N8 is Nokia's new flagship model. For the price premium... moreSure it might be able to run Symbian OS fine but what happens if someone were to try and port Android on the phone? Just how cheap the N8 hardware is relative to its exorbitant price is a massive put off

    thats exactly what i mean with my previous posts, nokia hardware is not that good compared with other brands like HTC, motorola, and sony ericsson. i think if n8 would be overclocked to 1ghz it will be able to run froyo, but definitely not gingerbread for it requires 512mb ram, and main side effect is the battery life... so i suggest on buying s8500 wave instead of n8 and that is a wiser decission.

      • ?
      • Anonymous
      • pqB
      • 05 Oct 2010

      miscof, 05 Oct 2010if u r talking about software what about nokia n900¿... moreLamer... N900 has the 3GS hardware and iOS isn't ported on anything because it's closed source and manufacturers aren't interested in it because it $ucks$.

      Here's why:
      1) http://theiphonefever.blogspot.com/2010/05/iphone-4g-screen-multimedia-flop.html

      2) http://theiphonefever.blogspot.com/p/idont-list.html

        • K
        • Killersmith
        • tA{
        • 05 Oct 2010

        miscof, 05 Oct 2010if u r talking about software what about nokia n900¿... moreI ve heard news that if you jump very hard, you will land on the moon......

          • m
          • miscof
          • vaQ
          • 05 Oct 2010

          francis fajardo , 04 Oct 2010if u r talking about software what about nokia n900¿ if u r talking about software what about nokia n900¿

          what are you talking about? n900, IMO, is a good phone, but still is lacking... ive heard news that an IOS was successfully ported to that phone, but due to its poor hardware being unable to compensate with IOS, the phones lags... so you see, most nokia phones are only good outside, but on the inside it really is not that good. i'd prefer the hardware of HTC, motorola, and sony ericsson over nokia, i mean they focus more on stuffs like battery, ui, ram, and other much more important features of a phone than with what you see in a phone itself like the softwares...

            • ?
            • Anonymous
            • pqB
            • 05 Oct 2010

            Steve Jobs's personal reply regarding N8!!!!

            Read it here: http://theiphonefever.blogspot.com/p/idont-list.html

              • ?
              • Anonymous
              • mEk
              • 05 Oct 2010

              W. Al Hakeem, 05 Oct 2010I know this is not the place to post this, but I have just ... moreYou can make FaceTime calls over 3G with my3g

                • a
                • akash from nepal
                • u10
                • 05 Oct 2010

                First to note is the N8′s
                image sizes. They’re
                incredibly compact. 12MP
                images are around 1-2MB.
                In comparison, the i8910
                form samsung has 8MP at
                3-4MB with the Panasonic
                Lumix TZ10 (camera) at a
                hefty 5MB for its 12MP
                shooter.
                With file compression, you
                loose a touch of detail.
                Remarkably that ’s less
                evident with the N8. This
                mod unfurls the
                compression from a slight
                1-2MB to 11MB.
                Just bask in that heavily
                noise reduced image. Look
                at the leaves and the
                clarity of the licence plate
                at this crop. Now the N8
                has very high detail
                anyway (despite what
                engadget shows in their
                tests), and it would be
                interesting to see a
                comparison image of non-
                hacked N8.

                  • W
                  • W. Al Hakeem
                  • mTV
                  • 05 Oct 2010

                  I know this is not the place to post this, but I have just posted yesterday here about my experience with iPhone 4 and mentioned that I didn't like the fact that video calls are available only to another iPhone and only through the WIFI. Today, in GsmArena under the iPhone 4 comments section I read a comment from a friend telling about a new application from Fringe (I think I got the name right) and it is now possible to make video calls to any other device working on any other operating system as well (!!) Quite impressive, I have to give it a try as soon as I get my hands on it :-) It's sure make my experience with the iPhone 4 better than it used to be.

                  Sorry again for posting this here but I didn't want the chance of someone reading my previous post and thinking that I was one of those misleading people posting their fake experience here and there.

                    • m
                    • my name is optional
                    • wrv
                    • 05 Oct 2010

                    I consider gsmarena has the best reviews, compared to others. Nuff said. Keep up the good work guys. Stay neutral. And as for those extremists/fanboys out there, would you mind to finish your school first before you post?

                      • W
                      • W. Al Hakeem
                      • mTV
                      • 05 Oct 2010

                      Anonymous, 05 Oct 2010Techradar sums up the N8 perfectly. "If a smaller c... moreWith all respect to your opinion and the conclusion you mentioned, I don't think that there is a battle to "Kill" the iPhone, if such a battle exists, personally I don't think that Samsung's Galaxy S is the one to win it, there are other contenders (in my opinion) that are more likely to win that place. But that's not the real issue here.

                      From the same article you copied, they mentioned that "... this is the biggest mobile manufacturer..." which has significat indications. They wouldn't have reached such a position if the top line units production (the N series) are "hardly ordinary", you need to be fair as well. I would agree with you if the comment was "N8 is not ground breaking device", "N8 might be a tep in the right direction from Nokia" but ordinary is a bit too much underetimating the (yet to be experienced) device :-)

                      You should have a look at the confirmed technical specifications like USB on the go, Bluetooth 3, FM transmitter along with a new setup on Symbian devices in terms of higher speed processor and increased RAM. I know that the numbers of Symbian 3 features are not even close to the huge ones we see in other HTC or Samsung or iPhone (1Ghz, +512 RAM...etc), but from a Symbian OS point of view, the numbers used now (be it speed or RAM) are good enough to produce good overall results with an important point kept in mind, power consumption. The higher processor speed does give you higher performance without any doupt, but at the cost of higher power consumption as well.

                      They are just different ways representing the phylosophy of the manufacturer and their vision of the device, which one to choose is completely up to the buyer / user.

                        • V
                        • VyK1ngg
                        • MFM
                        • 05 Oct 2010

                        I, for one, absolutely agree with this article!

                        'nuff said :-)

                          • n
                          • nokia user
                          • PF5
                          • 05 Oct 2010

                          This is outrageous!! N8 is awesome compared to that iphone 4....in many ways!! Just wait for the review here and see~

                            • e
                            • ek
                            • sSV
                            • 05 Oct 2010

                            gizmodo + engadget = Apple fanboys.
                            no surprise with their review.

                              • W
                              • W. Al Hakeem
                              • mTV
                              • 05 Oct 2010

                              Anonymous, 05 Oct 2010iPhone's set themselves up automatically, I've used differe... moreYour point is absolutely correct. But on the other hand, I'm using the iPhone, Nokia E90 and Samsung Omnia II currently and they all manage to get the connection settings without me having to do anything at all. It is for sure and important issue as not all of us are well familiar with the required network settings, but again, it's not just the iPhone that can do it. :-)

                                • W
                                • W. Al Hakeem
                                • mT%
                                • 05 Oct 2010

                                Jon SWE, 05 Oct 2010"If you have been keeping track of our review comments... moreThank you very much for taking the time to share what you found.

                                Well said and explained. Thanks again.

                                  • M
                                  • Mdfirerz
                                  • vj1
                                  • 05 Oct 2010

                                  q8phantom, 05 Oct 2010Where is the review GSMARENA! Still waiting. It's late, ... moreits already been proven by other review sites that n8's battery is excellent, its predictable since symbian is a very optimized os =p

                                    • ?
                                    • Anonymous
                                    • P%n
                                    • 05 Oct 2010

                                    Jon SWE, 05 Oct 2010"If you have been keeping track of our review comments... moreiPhone's set themselves up automatically, I've used different SIM's in unlocked ones and there is no setting up, you just connect to the Internet.

                                      • q
                                      • q8phantom
                                      • pVP
                                      • 05 Oct 2010

                                      Where is the review GSMARENA!

                                      Still waiting. It's late, I want to see if the battery is good or not, That's all what mostly care because I leave my msn messenger on all the time, so I need really a good battery, that will at least last from the early morning till bed time!

                                      If this is not the case with N8, I'll just stick with E72!

                                        • W
                                        • W. Al Hakeem
                                        • mT%
                                        • 05 Oct 2010

                                        [deleted post]Why don't you for a srart mind your languange and then maybe you'll have the time to think a little bit before exposing yourself that way on the public net?

                                        As an intellegent creature, why don't you educate us with your great knowledge of operating systems and tell us why you are against Symbian? and maybe if you still have some time tell us as well the greatness of other operating systems too? Did you actually use them and got deeply involved in their details to the level that makes you a source of judgement?

                                        Android is a great operating system, but with all respect to your high intellegence, if we took the example of computers / laptops, we have several operating systems, namely the Windows and MAC OS, can you tell which is better and which is not? (This is a hypothetical question by the way, you don't need to answer it at all, better concentrate on the knowledge you have on mobile phone operating systems).

                                        Many have criticised Android when it first came out, and look where they are today, They managed not to only live to the standards that others took years to reach, but they manage to compete with the ones already there.

                                        Share your valued experience that led you the conclusion you posted before and come back again (or don't, it doesn't really matter), but if you do, make syre to read the rules for posting here as this is respected site.