Apple has tested and rejected an in-display fingerprint reader for iPhones, says Mark Gurman

23 August 2021
Face ID is here to stay, though it might move behind the display on future high-end iPhones, according to the Bloomberg journalist.

Sort by:

  • ?
  • Anonymous
  • LkB
  • 24 Aug 2021

Strawhat, 24 Aug 2021so punchole vs notch, it is better a huge notch according t... moreNotch is least ugly and be be hidden when using apps, on old android phones.
You cant hide the mole hole.

    • ?
    • Anonymous
    • TL%
    • 24 Aug 2021

    Anonymous, 24 Aug 2021What exactly do you base this on? Secure face ID is by f... moreTry using with a mask on, lol. And fingerprint biometric is always more secure than face.

      • ?
      • Anonymous
      • 0cJ
      • 24 Aug 2021

      SMIRNAS, 24 Aug 2021Apple Marketing be like,, We proudly present to you, our mo... moreWhat exactly do you base this on?

      Secure face ID is by far the best, in my experience. I have never had a fingerprint scanner as reliable as Face ID, and my current Xiaomi under-screen scanner fails to unlock on the first try about 40% of the time, and totally fails about 20%.

      And the cost statement is nonsense: Face ID is far more expensive to implement securely, which is why the vast majority of Chinese brands don't do.

        • k
        • kek
        • GBh
        • 24 Aug 2021

        I'm pretty sure the reason Apple backtracked is because they probably put it under certain specific scenarios and it probably failed at it. And by "specific scenarios", I mean something pretty rare, like a wet finger using it or something like that

          Apple Marketing be like,, We proudly present to you, our most Innovative product yet

          Apple executives be like,, "nope, this in-display fingertprint isn't cheap enough yet."

            AnonD-1003038, 23 Aug 2021Why do you care so much when you wouldn't ever touch a... moreso punchole vs notch, it is better a huge notch according to your logic?

              • h
              • h
              • m2J
              • 23 Aug 2021

              For my security reasons i dont want any biometric system on my phone for lock screen or anything. The less info of me on my phone the better for me. Biometric info of me either my face or fingerprint can be used against me when i lose my phone or being hacked or for some reason these get leaked. I make my own security and dont need to depend on a flawed systems that have vulnerabilities, that is basically all digital. There is noting impossible in technology and programming. It wont be easy but it's not impossible. We are not able to do something now that dont mean we cant do it in a year or two so using this world impossible is dumb excuse

                • ?
                • Anonymous
                • LkB
                • 23 Aug 2021

                Mel, 23 Aug 2021You are right, I hate curve screen too. I love flat. My s21... moreI think zen8 has.
                Also many chinese midranges.
                Do not know if mote 20 edge pro has.

                  • ?
                  • Anonymous
                  • gxj
                  • 23 Aug 2021

                  Finally someone who understands that UD fingerprint reader isn't much mature and needs a lot of workaround
                  The fact that apple is still on top is they always use the mature tech not a beta tester like Samsung and Xiaomi

                    • ?
                    • Anonymous
                    • LkB
                    • 23 Aug 2021

                    Good guy, 23 Aug 2021Those complaining about UDFPS you better check gen 2 Ultras... moreI think it is same used by Sharp.
                    Larger area.

                      Tiramisu, 23 Aug 2021Touch ID on the side of the phone isn't a major redesign. "Contrary to some rumors, the fingerprint reader will not return to mainline iPhones"

                      Did you at least read the first paragraph?

                        travstr, 23 Aug 2021dunno which phones you been buying but you are doing someth... moreNo I just have a different opinion than you. Personally my favorite positioning is the side mounted power button sensor. I'd take the rear sensor next.

                          • D
                          • AnonD-762416
                          • Sec
                          • 23 Aug 2021

                          Mel, 23 Aug 2021Zflip for sure is not recommended in display because is a f... moreNo one has a phone without a lock any more, you can't use things like Google Play without it. So, you have to use the fingerprint reader. Like I said, I own both the Flip and S21U and the in display fingerprint reader in the S21U is superior for daily use. Unlocks as easily with the left hand as the right hand. The sensor Samsung uses isn't a useless optical sensor like Chinese phones use. It isn't sensitive to light. It works the same day and night.

                            dbjungle, 23 Aug 2021You're wrong. You don't know me. I buy a lot of... moredunno which phones you been buying but you are doing something wrong. I've had great experiences using under display sensors between Huawei and Samsung. and there was recently a Vivo (I believe) phone that was previewed with a huge sensor big enough for multiple fingers that is literally instant as soon as the screen is pressed. so the technology is not only there, but it's much better than feeling on the back of the phone. don't have to lift the device anywhere to use the fingerprint - what's not to love? reevaluate.

                              • P
                              • Profits.
                              • nC4
                              • 23 Aug 2021

                              Even midrange phone can have superb and fast scanners, yet as known with Apple, it is all about minimum spending and profits.

                                travstr, 23 Aug 2021...said by someone who's never used one before, clearly.You're wrong. You don't know me. I buy a lot of phones. I've had 4 phones with UD fingerprint. It's slower and less accurate than a dedicated capacitive fingerprint sensor. It's a waste of money as far as I'm concerned and I wish companies wouldn't bring this trash technology into the market until it is on par with the outgoing technology.

                                  Bestowed an infinite number of variables directing to a multitudinous number of potential upshots in the macrocosm with an eternity of time constraint within the restriction of natural law, anything that can happen will happen anywhere at some conferred time.
                                  apple:hold my notch!

                                    • T
                                    • Tiramisu
                                    • dZt
                                    • 23 Aug 2021

                                    OhNom, 23 Aug 2021* coughs, coughs * "Of course this is all a discuss... moreTouch ID on the side of the phone isn't a major redesign.

                                      • ?
                                      • Anonymous
                                      • xq5
                                      • 23 Aug 2021

                                      Poor company. Can't figure out that simple and basic feature that even mid range android phones do easily.

                                        • D
                                        • AnonD-909757
                                        • pZV
                                        • 23 Aug 2021

                                        Why was I hoping Apple to do something intelligent and help bring ultrasonic FPS to the masses?
                                        Yep, never again I'll associate "intelligent", "clever", "smart" or "ingenious" with the smartphone market, its OEMs and its community, it would be an insult to those words.